Jump to content

ERCOT, PUC, and deregulation got us here


cactusflinthead

Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, Aqua Buddha said:

30 seconds of exhaustive internet research told me that Oklahoma gets 32% of their power from wind yet they stayed operational.  Maybe it's not wind's fault, after all.

40+ percent of Iowa's energy comes from wind. Pretty sure it gets cold there too. Source: https://www.nsenergybusiness.com/features/wind-power-states-us/

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

57 minutes ago, PenelopeWitherspoon said:

I have always been pro-nuclear.  South Texas Project has been a boon for the most part.  

Is it fair to say, in the midst of this epic failure and zero sum game, there are many companies that have made a mint, many that will be bankrupted, and the cost of their bankruptcies will be shouldered by .....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, disgustipated said:

Is it fair to say, in the midst of this epic failure and zero sum game, there are many companies that have made a mint, many that will be bankrupted, and the cost of their bankruptcies will be shouldered by .....

This whole debate of wind/solar/gas/coal is kabuki theater designed to distract attention from the proximate, solvable cause of the crisis. The huge capital intensive projects and long term build out of power plants is decided and will not be changed, there will be lots of finger pointing and then what was going to happen will happen. It’s not analogous to turning around an aircraft carrier—- it’s building an aircraft carrier, launching, sailing, turning around , scrapping and then building a submarine instead. 
 

No one will come out and say “we could have built all this shit so that it would function in cold. We didn’t because it didn’t make financial sense because Texas usually doesn’t get this cold. And it still doesn’t make financial sense so we’re not going to go upgrade it.”

If they said that people would make them go do it, and they don’t want to. 

  • Hook 'Em 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, 956 Worldwide said:

This whole debate of wind/solar/gas/coal is kabuki theater designed to distract attention from the proximate, solvable cause of the crisis. The huge capital intensive projects and long term build out of power plants is decided and will not be changed, there will be lots of finger pointing and then what was going to happen will happen. It’s not analogous to turning around an aircraft carrier—- it’s building an aircraft carrier, launching, sailing, turning around , scrapping and then building a submarine instead. 
 

No one will come out and say “we could have built all this shit so that it would function in cold. We didn’t because it didn’t make financial sense because Texas usually doesn’t get this cold. And it still doesn’t make financial sense so we’re not going to go upgrade it.”

If they said that people would make them go do it, and they don’t want to. 

My point, specific to this incident, is it fair to say there are power traders in this market that made their numbers for the year, REP's  that were not appropriately hedged, and someone who is going to foot the bill, and who is that someone.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 2/16/2021 at 4:14 PM, cactusflinthead said:

 

I'm several pages and a couple of days behind (partially due to our deregulated electricity market), but I need to chime in here. Although Troy has retired to Horseshoe Bay, he's not from there. I went to high school with his daughter and his good-for-nothing shithead son. While Troy portrayed himself locally as a pillar of the First Baptist Church, whenever he was away Sunny would host gigantic, open-bar parties for all of us fellow underaged high schoolers at their hacienda. Troy, himself, was always an "aw shucks" kind of guy around town, but even at the age of 16, I easily figured out he was a total shyster. Sunny was smart enough, decent, and okay, but her younger brother was an absolute shit, who took much more after his dad, and was a total cokehead. He eventually got arrested on 6th Street in Austin while his dad was still in office. /csb

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Brisketexan said:


Again, Penelope with well-stated and succinct truth. Seriously, I may propose to this lovely woman. I’m sure my wife would be ok with it.
 

You spent the last few months gobbling up cheek kisses from Whiggins and now you're running your mouth in public about proposing to Penelope? Look, I'd never tell a fellow playa how to roll, but you're about to get knifed by someone. 

  • Like 1
  • Haha 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Doc Sam Beckett said:

You spent the last few months gobbling up cheek kisses from Whiggins and now you're running your mouth in public about proposing to Penelope? Look, I'd never tell a fellow playa how to roll, but you're about to get knifed by someone. 

don't hate the playa... 

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

40 minutes ago, SydneyCarton said:

Listen, I’m not saying it is, but what I am doing is trying to ascribe the right responsibility and blame to those most culpable. Homes and WallStreet aren’t basic functions either, nor is a college education, but we’ve managed to fuck over the fortunes of plenty of folks that way too. I’m discussing a mentality. 
 

what do you do to change bad behaviors? You penalize those responsible and vote out those who give them cover. Same as it ever was, dude. 

Agree, and it's actually more egregious to fuck over basic services like this.  The social compact continues to get kicked in the balls repeatedly on multiple fronts, but losing the ability to provide essential services is even more over the top.  The political system can't and won't change this because it's been crippled and there's no clear view as to how it will get healed.

Edited by SizzleChest
  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, 956 Worldwide said:

Can you imagine the mental state of a person who is freezing their balls off because power plants in the world’s wealthiest and most powerful nation didn’t winterize—- and the immediate target of his anger is REFUGEES! 

His screen name was "Ags4DaWin," so it really doesn't take much imagination.

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You spent the last few months gobbling up cheek kisses from Whiggins and now you're running your mouth in public about proposing to Penelope? Look, I'd never tell a fellow playa how to roll, but you're about to get knifed by someone. 


I’m looking into becoming LDS. Get me a whole passel of smart wives. All I have to do is become handsome and charming enough to convince multiple women to marry me.

That may present a significant hurdle.

Agree, and it's actually more egregious to fuck over basic services like this.  The social compact continues to get kicked in the balls repeatedly on multiple fronts, but losing the ability to provide essential services is even more over the top.  The political system can't and won't change this because it's been crippled and there's no clear view as to how it will get healed.


The social compact is dead. The only thing that matters is dollars and profits. Everything else, including you and your life, is worthy only as sacrifices on the altar of profit for the very few. That’s what we have chosen. And we’ll fight to the death to keep it that way.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, SydneyCarton said:

I can’t give you a citation, man. It’s just my business. Add up the employees that handle deregulated energy at reliant, txu, direct energy (now txu), entrust, Gexa, champion energy, constellation energy, plus the hundreds of small REPs that have cycled through the Texas marketplace. That’s people handling marketing, trading, pricing, operations, support staff, sales, public relations, business development. Now consider the contract labor associated with those businesses, partnership vendors, and probably a dozen of other avenues or more I’m missing. These businesses also support call center staff in bulk, which means software and CIS support. Oh let’s not forget tech and IT, plus contracts with cloud computing and storage. It’s a lot of motherfucking jobs and business that contributes to the economy, dude. I can spend time mapping it out when I’m not scrounging for fucking toilet water, dude, or you can take my word for it. 

i still think you're off by an order of magnitude.

 

 

also, hooray, we employed a bunch of middle men whose job definitely wasn't to make sure that power worked when you really needed it.  maybe we should have had them do that and skip the whole naming stadiums thing.

Edited by elfenix
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, PenelopeWitherspoon said:

I completely agree with you.  I am in support of deregulation and consumer choice.  I know you have been without power, but I have been trying to explain to a lot of people how ERCOT works.  I may not be in the industry anymore, but I still remember how it all works.  

hqdefault.jpg

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, elfenix said:

i still think you're off by an order of magnitude.

An order of magnitude? So if I said 200k Youd say 20k? I had a long typed out screed about the # of employees DE had in greenway plaza, how many folks are in a medium sized call center, the door to door industry, but fuck it. You’re going to think what you want to think. Youre generally a great poster so I have no interest in getting in a passing contest with you.  
 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

59 minutes ago, Brisketexan said:

 


I’m looking into becoming LDS. Get me a whole passel of smart wives. All I have to do is become handsome and charming enough to convince multiple women to marry me.

That may present a significant hurdle.



The social compact is dead. The only thing that matters is dollars and profits. Everything else, including you and your life, is worthy only as sacrifices on the altar of profit for the very few. That’s what we have chosen. And we’ll fight to the death to keep it that way.

 

I have one wife.  Why the fuck would I want more than that?  You have been on the ledge too long.  

  • Hook 'Em 2
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, SydneyCarton said:

An order of magnitude? So if I said 200k Youd say 20k? I had a long typed out screed about the # of employees DE had in greenway plaza, how many folks are in a medium sized call center, the door to door industry, but fuck it. You’re going to think what you want to think. Youre generally a great poster so I have no interest in getting in a passing contest with you.  
 

 

*pissing

🙃

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Brisketexan said:

The social compact is dead. The only thing that matters is dollars and profits. Everything else, including you and your life, is worthy only as sacrifices on the altar of profit for the very few. That’s what we have chosen. And we’ll fight to the death to keep it that way.

So you think Republican donors, on the whole, are profiting from this disaster?  This is far more a case of stupidity and incompetence than malfeasance.  

Even for power generators, the blow back is going to far outweigh whatever corners they had been cutting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, SydneyCarton said:

Autocorrect can die on a fire. Was typing in my car. 

I like it. While CTJ is racing other posters, some of us who don't like to run can challenge you in a passing contest. We'll have more ticket sales that way.

Edited by SquishMitten
  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, WBT said:

So you think Republican donors, on the whole, are profiting from this disaster?  This is far more a case of stupidity and incompetence than malfeasance.  

Even for power generators, the blow back is going to far outweigh whatever corners they had been cutting.

They profited until now. And somehow they'll end up with federal subsidies to bail them out of this disaster. Zero incentive to fix anything or behave better. 

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, longhornmatt said:

I don’t know why you and CTJ insist on solving everything by 40 yard dashes and adult punt, pass and kick competitions.  People have real problems to deal with and no time for that tomfoolery, Sydney! 

Sigh. And I can say it wouldn’t be much of a contest. I can’t throw for shit. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, longhornmatt said:

I assume there will be something arranged where public funds are used to winterize gas lines and wells.  It would be good for the O&G industry and for Texas, and the industry would happily accept someone else paying for it.

Yes, Flyin Ted and Cowboy John will lobby Biden to include this in the infrastructure bill. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, WBT said:

So you think Republican donors, on the whole, are profiting from this disaster?  This is far more a case of stupidity and incompetence than malfeasance.  

Even for power generators, the blow back is going to far outweigh whatever corners they had been cutting.

There’s not going to BE any blowback, at least of the coordinated, focused sort that leads to consequences and changed behavior. Forget it, the time has passed, that window is closed.
 

This is how disinformation campaigns work, and what you are seeing is a coordinated disinformation campaign. Every bit of available political oxygen is getting sucked up in an argument over whether wind and solar is to blame, or big bad dinosaur juice; whether to kick and scream against the imaginary Green New Deal, or double down on renewable. 
 

All of that has shit-all to do with what actually happened (basically, none of our shit had insulation installed). It’s like Russians and the Malaysia Air downing. (It was the Americans? The Ukrainians? A plane full of dead bodies with a bomb on board?) 

The point isn’t to make up a believable story. It’s enough just to make people spend all their time debunking your bullshit and then there’s no will or energy to actually hold you accountable. 

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, Dahobbs said:

They profited until now. And somehow they'll end up with federal subsidies to bail them out of this disaster. Zero incentive to fix anything or behave better. 

Yes, businesses with little or no regulation do not plan for the future if they know they will never face any consequences from fucking up.  They only care about the next quarter's earnings report.  When making decisions, they will always choose the option that means more profit now. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Ted Lange said:

 

 

Yeah. Once the grid goes down, getting it back up is a fucking nightmare, as we’ve seen. This wasn’t an ERCOT problem. Although I’d be critical a bit of what I saw as an overabundance of caution bringing more power online to residents...but I also wasn’t in the room for those conversations and don’t understand what the available generation was/has been...

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, kevwun said:

Yes, businesses with little or no regulation do not plan for the future if they know they will never face any consequences from fucking up.  They only care about the next quarter's earnings report.  When making decisions, they will always choose the option that means more profit now. 

spacer.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So you think Republican donors, on the whole, are profiting from this disaster?  This is far more a case of stupidity and incompetence than malfeasance.  
Even for power generators, the blow back is going to far outweigh whatever corners they had been cutting.



They profited right up till this moment. And their political protectors will make sure that they are protected from any blowback. I mean, why would there be any blowback? This was all AOC’s fault.


They profited until now. And somehow they'll end up with federal subsidies to bail them out of this disaster. Zero incentive to fix anything or behave better. 



BINGO.


There’s not going to BE any blowback, at least of the coordinated, focused sort that leads to consequences and changed behavior. Forget it, the time has passed, that window is closed.
 
This is how disinformation campaigns work, and what you are seeing is a coordinated disinformation campaign. Every bit of available political oxygen is getting sucked up in an argument over whether wind and solar is to blame, or big bad dinosaur juice; whether to kick and scream against the imaginary Green New Deal, or double down on renewable. 
 
All of that has shit-all to do with what actually happened (basically, none of our shit had insulation installed). It’s like Russians and the Malaysia Air downing. (It was the Americans? The Ukrainians? A plane full of dead bodies with a bomb on board?) 
The point isn’t to make up a believable story. It’s enough just to make people spend all their time debunking your bullshit and then there’s no will or energy to actually hold you accountable. 

Yes, businesses with little or no regulation do not plan for the future if they know they will never face any consequences from fucking up.  They only care about the next quarter's earnings report.  When making decisions, they will always choose the option that means more profit now. 




Two perfect posts. Y’all understand how this works.

There is the concept of profits, and the concept of the public good. Profits are God. The common good is the devil. It’s not any more complicated than that.

Our leadership chose a path that literally kills people in order to add an extra margin to the profits of their donors. You think those fuckers are going to sprout a conscience NOW? They will do what they’ve already done: lie, deflect all blame, and find a way to make this ANOTHER profit-making opportunity at the expense of the common good.

When someone tells and shows you what they are, over and over and over and over and over and over and over....believe them. If shooting you in the face would put an extra $10 in the pocket of a Republican donor, Abbott Cruz Patrick Paxton would gleefully pull the trigger themselves. Don’t listen to me....watch what they have done and are doing right now.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

36 minutes ago, WBT said:

So you think Republican donors, on the whole, are profiting from this disaster?  This is far more a case of stupidity and incompetence than malfeasance.  

Even for power generators, the blow back is going to far outweigh whatever corners they had been cutting.

It's really important that we dispel the myth that a cadre of Big Cigars rule the Republican party from a smoky humidor. Rich Republicans don't give a shit if life for us devolves back into Sherwood Forest. First, they think everything is fine, because they're not personally suffering, and don't really have it in them to imagine what things are like for people who are suffering. Second, they'll always have a Sheriff of Nottingham to protect them. Their reaction to heightened instability among the lower and middle classes will only lead them to invest in better security systems, taller fences, and more powerful backup generators.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, SquishMitten said:

Only chance this is different than anything else (and actual change happens), it's going to be because this affected everyone regardless of wealth. Super rich folks lost power as well. That's not usually the case.

Harvey was also an equal opportunity asshole and Houston's done nothing. Can't wait for this year's thousand-year storm. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Correct. It also happened in 2002. No, I don’t want to pay more for electricity for 10 year storms. ERCOT really fucked up, but any explanation will likely be lost on this crowd. And lol at the Highland Park graphic, and generally anytime Wanker Bob posts. 

Let’s not pay any more for electricity, even a few dollars a month.

Also, let’s suffer a disaster that will end up being the costliest in the history of the United States, per early insurance estimates.

Not sure I agree with your math there, Lou.
Link to comment
Share on other sites



×
×
  • Create New...