Jump to content

2018 Home Run Derby


Goo Punch

Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, henrygandorf said:

when i was little (the 80's) they used to rerun old home run derby tv shows that were from the 50's and 60's.  mantle and mays and many others were in them.  does anyone else remember what i'm talking about?  they were black and white and were just two people, head to head, for a half hour show.  i have no idea what channel it was but probably espn2 or something.

Pretty sure that was WGN. I watched it quite a few times because it was cool getting to see footage of guys like Ernie Banks, Mays and Mantle who I had never really seen before.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, PappyVanVinceYoung said:

It seems so unfair though. Hasn’t been the case this year, but last year Bour got eliminated in the first round hitting 22 while Sano moved on hitting 11. That just seems absurd. 

Also, the time limit penalizes players that hit high homeruns since it takes longer for them to land. What kind of sense does that make?

 

yeah because 10 swings and you're done is totally fair. schwarber would have been the first one out tonight if that were the case.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I’m ready to start a movement to replace extra innings with a round of HR derby.   Use the same timed format as the current derby except you can sub in a batter any time you want and no timeouts.  Pitcher can be anyone currently available as a sub on the roster.  Who’s with me?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, Guadaloopy said:

I’m ready to start a movement to replace extra innings with a round of HR derby.   Use the same timed format as the current derby except you can sub in a batter any time you want and no timeouts.  Pitcher can be anyone currently available as a sub on the roster.  Who’s with me?

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

There are Home Run Derby truthers accusing Bryce Harper's dad of cheating

Quote

Nationals superstar Bryce Harper on Monday night won the 2018 Home Run Derby in his home ballpark and in front of tens of thousands of adoring Nats fans. Making it all the more dramatic is that Harper prevailed over Cubs slugger Kyle Schwarber in a hotly contested final round. And that's where the plot thickens. 

Per Derby rules, the pitcher is supposed to wait until each batted ball lands before delivering the next pitch. In Harper's case, he was off Schwarber's final-round pace of 18 home runs by five with less than one minute on the clock. Harper began closing the gap, and as the clock wound down, Harper's pitcher -- his dad, Ron, it should be noted -- appeared to break that "wait until the ball lands" rule on multiple occasions. Have a look:

It's not over until @Bharper3407 says it's over. pic.twitter.com/UATq8M2ldV

— MLB (@MLB) July 17, 2018

So r we just ignoring the fact the Bryce Harper & his dad cheated & did not follow the rules of the #HomeRunDerby ? The previous hit ball must hit the ground before the next ball can be thrown to the batter. Harper needs 4 Home Runs taken away, video evidence. #Justice4Schwarberpic.twitter.com/u0B5FPAlfV

— Franchise 🤘KLiQ🤘 (@FranchiseKicks) July 17, 2018

(Yes, there's a seemingly earnest #Justice4Schwarber hashtag making the rounds, and -- in another modern inevitability -- there's a Change.org petition to recognize Schwarber as the rightful Derby champ.) This kind of thing, it should be noted, was not a particularly isolated reaction: 

My absolute favorite thing in the world right now is Cubs fan home run derby truthers who believe the Harpers were cheating pic.twitter.com/F7QEvPt5pj

— Dan Steinberg (@dcsportsbog) July 17, 2018

What's interesting is that there's an ump positioned far behind home plate who signals to the pitcher when it's OK to throw again. By way of example, here's that ump letting Rhys Hoskins' pitcher know that he's free to serve up another one (as said other one has already been served up):

screen-shot-2018-07-17-at-10-14-54-am.png

Did you know there is an umpire for the Derby? MLB.tv screengrab

So was Harper's dad ignoring the hold sign from the ump or was the ump "going rogue" and giving him the green light before those baseballs had landed? That, people, is the ultimately unimportant question. 

 

Also, let it be known that other 2018 Derby participants where not spared from such accusations: 

@teixeiramark25 are we just gonna pretend like Hoskins didn’t cheat? He wasn’t waiting for the ball to land

— Jake Robinson (@JDR316) July 17, 2018

And, yes, Schwarber himself as at least one righteous accuser out there: 

Well I got Hoskins, Muncy, and Harper right, and would have gotten Bregman if Schwarber didn't cheat.#HomeRunDerby

— Randy (@randyscholz) July 17, 2018

At this point, two key takeaways: 

  1. Ditch the stupid rule, and let participants pitch and swing with all the haste and impunity they can muster.
  2. It's the Home Run Derby. It's an exercise in fun. If you're Mad Online about any bending of the rules, then your interior life is your own punishment. 

Bryce Harper won the 2018 Home Run Derby. 

Counterpoint:

Spoiler


Quote

Shaana, they bought their tickets, they knew what they were getting into.  I say, ban Bryce from the HOF.


 

 

Edited by clapclapclap
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...