Jump to content

Turns Out E-Scooters Might Be The End of Society


Doc Reeves

Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, gsoda3 said:

Nothing wrong with the scooters, just the people who make bad decisions on them.

Check out how this guy rides. He's a cool dude but the way he rides I fear for his safety.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That looks awesome. I mean it’s going to create a whole new generation of quadriplegics and the manufacturers will be sued into oblivion because folks who can’t operate their legs well think they are going to ride a motorized tire 25 mph, but it looks cool. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 hours ago, Lhorn said:

That looks awesome. I mean it’s going to create a whole new generation of quadriplegics and the manufacturers will be sued into oblivion because folks who can’t operate their legs well think they are going to ride a motorized tire 25 mph, but it looks cool. 

That's the problem - he makes it look fucking cool as shit. I mean, look at this video right here. It's not only his riding skills, but his video and editing skills However, he's one of the few people with the skills to weave through heavy traffic like that and not die.

They organize big group rides in NYC and San Francisco. I just started riding but I'm not good enough to join them. If I do, I'm going to ride like a sane human that wants to stay alive.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/4/2019 at 10:40 AM, Doc Reeves said:

a guy my wife has known since HS fell off and hit his head bad. It’s been about a year and it’s a full on ‘Regarding Henry’ situation. The guy is connected to a big-time family here in TX and they are planning to go scorched earth with a class-action 

I hate those goddamn scooters and probably wish death on most of the fuckwits zipping around on them but your friend is a fucking cunt.  he’s a fucking adult and if he’s dumb enough to ride one of those things he should accept the consequences.   too many people now are fragile pussies that simply refuse to accept responsibility for the results of their own bad decisions.  it’s an exponentially bigger problem than the fucking scooters. 

  • Like 7
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/10/2019 at 2:26 PM, Lobo said:

Many of you would have apparently kept automobiles from coming to market  

That automobiles are established in the market is reason #1 that scooters shouldn't be.

Physics, how does it work?

Edited by Cajun
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Lobo
2 hours ago, Cajun said:

That automobiles are established in the market is reason #1 that scooters shouldn't be.

Physics, how does it work?

Physics work the same way that the odds a person dying in an automobile are much higher than they are on a scooter.  

Cars and horses and pedestrians didn't get along very well for decades.  They still don't, but thankfully horses moved out of the way. 

Adler's vision zero conveniently skips over the needless deaths in Austin to motorists, bicycle riders, and scooter riders.  Our road system isn't just inconvenient and a time-suck, a great deal of it is woefully unsafe and we've turned down opportunities to address chunks of it in the very recent past.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Lobo

I know that we're doubling down on our desire to not properly expand the roads.  But we've also cut a lot of safety corners along the way as well.  Something I was not so prepared to learn about, very troubling that's not just about ease of rush hour, but how some of our roads and intersections are much more dangerous than they need to be because of our desire to place capital resources elsewhere.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Lobo said:

Physics work the same way that the odds a person dying in an automobile are much higher than they are on a scooter.  

Good try, but not even close.

Imagine the number of scooters sharing the roads with the same number of cars/trucks/etc.  

Now trot out your argument.  Sample sizes ≠ Physics

And, please, let's not revisit the false equivalency of the horse/car/scooter whathaveyou.  Bush League Psych-Out STUFF!

 

Edit: The rest of your post I have no quarrel with.

Edited by Cajun
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heres my take after losing my e scooter virginity this afternoon. 

Me and my buddy were riding them between deep ellum through Downton to uptown Dallas. 

They are fun but takes a bit to get the hang of. I maybe almost fell once but nothing major. If you are lacking in coordination or have no experience riding scooters I can see how it would be easy to eat shit. 

My friend who was more fucked up ended up falling and scratching his knee and dirtying up his shorts but nothing bad 

It was fun and still kind of exercising with the control you have to display over distance (just light legs and upper body). I never felt like a helmet was needed. Unless you got t- boned by a car or something but in that case you're a fucking dumbass. It isn't any more dangerous than a longboard or bmx. I kind of side with if you want to take the risk go for it - but I do think it's a little too accessible to the mouth breathing demographic that will do shit like run into cars or break an ankle.

Edited by ztejas
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Cajun said:

Good try, but not even close.

Imagine the number of scooters sharing the roads with the same number of cars/trucks/etc.  

Now trot out your argument.  Sample sizes ≠ Physics

And, please, let's not revisit the false equivalency of the horse/car/scooter whathaveyou.  Bush League Psych-Out STUFF!

 

Edit: The rest of your post I have no quarrel with.

Nah man you're much more likely to die while riding in a car. He's right that it is physics. There is much more potentially dangerous kinetic energy occurring in any car crash than someone being thrown off a scooter 3 inches off of the ground. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nah man you're much more likely to die while riding in a car. He's right that it is physics. There is much more potentially dangerous kinetic energy occurring in any car crash than someone being thrown off a scooter 3 inches off of the ground. 

Let’s see statistics on deaths per mile traveled for cars as compared to scooters before making any conclusions
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, futureman said:

I hate those goddamn scooters and probably wish death on most of the fuckwits zipping around on them but your friend is a fucking cunt.  he’s a fucking adult and if he’s dumb enough to ride one of those things he should accept the consequences.   too many people now are fragile pussies that simply refuse to accept responsibility for the results of their own bad decisions.  it’s an exponentially bigger problem than the fucking scooters. 

Seems you’re more interested in his means than the data. 

Believe me, the guy I’m talking about pays for his bad decision of getting on one of those things every single day until lights out

This isn’t a question of people being snowflakes, this is a loophole in common sense city ordinances that are in place around the world. 

This isn’t saying people are fragile, it’s saying that this activity is so fucking dangerously stupid that idiots who do it need to follow minimum safety standards so they don’t waste the time of our emts, Drs, cops and whoever else has to deal with their broken brain. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, Doc Reeves said:

Seems you’re more interested in his means than the data. 

Believe me, the guy I’m talking about pays for his bad decision of getting on one of those things every single day until lights out

This isn’t a question of people being snowflakes, this is a loophole in common sense city ordinances that are in place around the world. 

This isn’t saying people are fragile, it’s saying that this activity is so fucking dangerously stupid that idiots who do it need to follow minimum safety standards so they don’t waste the time of our emts, Drs, cops and whoever else has to deal with their broken brain. 

it’s a fucking scooter.  he’s an adult.  does he need to be told to wear a helmet?  or to not get on the damn thing in the first place?  I think they should all be destroyed and outlawed but still, anyone with half a brain should understand the possible consequences of riding around city streets on a motorized skateboard.  and if I were stupid enough to do it and ate shit and broke my brain I can’t see at all how it’s not 100% my fault.  precisely why I’ll never ride one of those goddamn things. 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

In Downtown Austin over the weekend for first time in years.  No news flash, but damn, I was shocked by how many there were.  Wife and I walked a bit and got cut off on the sidewalk no fewer than three times.  One "gentleman" sort of scoffed as we were trying to cross the street and my wife was walking down the little handicap ramp into the crosswalk, like he was in HER way.  Dick.

 

Anyways, add another "old" to the "f the scooters, man" camp.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, Doc Reeves said:

Seems you’re more interested in his means than the data. 

Believe me, the guy I’m talking about pays for his bad decision of getting on one of those things every single day until lights out

This isn’t a question of people being snowflakes, this is a loophole in common sense city ordinances that are in place around the world. 

This isn’t saying people are fragile, it’s saying that this activity is so fucking dangerously stupid that idiots who do it need to follow minimum safety standards so they don’t waste the time of our emts, Drs, cops and whoever else has to deal with their broken brain. 

I don't think it's any more dangerous than snow skiing, snowboarding, skateboarding, riding a bike, etc.

Like I said it's just really cheap and accessible so you have a bunch of idiots hopping on them and being... idiots. The safety of the activity largely depends on the  operator.

Edited by ztejas
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 hours ago, Doc Reeves said:

Seems you’re more interested in his means than the data. 

Believe me, the guy I’m talking about pays for his bad decision of getting on one of those things every single day until lights out

This isn’t a question of people being snowflakes, this is a loophole in common sense city ordinances that are in place around the world. 

This isn’t saying people are fragile, it’s saying that this activity is so fucking dangerously stupid that idiots who do it need to follow minimum safety standards so they don’t waste the time of our emts, Drs, cops and whoever else has to deal with their broken brain. 

So your friend and his family are doing this solely for the public good and not looking for any financial compensation?  Great.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, ztejas said:

The safety of the activity largely depends on the  operator.

And everyone around them. There are plenty of ways to be seriously hurt on these scooters even while being the smart/safe operator that you assume yourself to be.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They are showing up in more and more places around here, but the only place I've ever ridden one was when I was in Austin last fall.  They were EVERYWHERE.  Actually really convenient for an urban area, but it did seem wildly dangerous.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The scooters don't belong on sidewalks. They shouldn't be on the road with cars either. There should be a network of dedicated lanes for these types of vehicles. 

But you don't get there magically. No city's going to build the infrastructure without a crisis to drive it. A few lanes here and there isn't enough to get people from A to B. Hence this clusterfuck is a necessary step. I hope it gets worse so we can build the damn thing.

Remember, the alternative is these people hailing Ubers and Lyfts, which has made traffic fuck-awful.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, trauma babe said:

And everyone around them. There are plenty of ways to be seriously hurt on these scooters even while being the smart/safe operator that you assume yourself to be.

I guess we should start regulating walking down the streets as well...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/10/2019 at 2:15 PM, ajax said:

Check out how this guy rides. He's a cool dude but the way he rides I fear for his safety.

 

Wrong. Not a cool dude. Not a cool dude at all.

The main problem with scooters is that they're way too fast for sidewalks and way too slow for streets. I fucking hate them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i'm cool with them until it affects me personally, then my opinion may or may not change.  hot take, I know.  Anything to get more cars off the road is a step in the right direction, but cities are going to have to be forced into doing something about them.  Either banning or embracing them by making special lanes after the fact.  

I would like to see the data on injuries between these and hoverboards.  

They are starting to make stuff like this:  https://www.businessinsider.com/a-new-inflatable-collar-is-safer-than-the-traditional-bike-helmet-2018-8 that would not be too bad to carry around if you knew you would be getting on scooters to get around downtown or something.  carrying around a traditional helmet is deal breaker.  people would rather be unsafe than have to carry around one of those.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, Charles DeMar said:

In Downtown Austin over the weekend for first time in years.  No news flash, but damn, I was shocked by how many there were.  Wife and I walked a bit and got cut off on the sidewalk no fewer than three times.  One "gentleman" sort of scoffed as we were trying to cross the street and my wife was walking down the little handicap ramp into the crosswalk, like he was in HER way.  Dick.

 

Anyways, add another "old" to the "f the scooters, man" camp.

 

 

that happens a lot with bikes too.  if people would adhere to the rules of biking while on a scooter that'd go to solve lots of problems.  problem is, scooters are more accessible than bikes so there are a lot of people who have no experience riding bikes in urban settings getting on scooters.  i think it's just a growing pain.  

 

the eyesore that is scooters littering the landscape though, that's another issue that needs to be addressed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, irishtexan said:

Wrong. Not a cool dude. Not a cool dude at all.

The main problem with scooters is that they're way too fast for sidewalks and way too slow for streets. I fucking hate them.

He's a cool dude.

 

And your takeaway is that they're not going fast enough? Lol. Sure.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When these things started popping up in downtown Dallas, I thought it was an interesting -- albeit potentially -- dangerous addition to getting around the city. I still haven't gotten up the courage to jump on one. At that time I went looking to see where you could ride them. I don't recall the details but it made it seem like you can't ride them on sidewalks in downtown Dallas or Deep Ellum and you also can't ride them on the street when the MPH was a certain speed or higher. I remember thinking that eliminated both streets and sidewalks in downtown/Deep Ellum but nobody is paying attention to those rules. My cousin's husband has started one of these companies in San Antonio.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I’m not afraid to say I ride them. I’m old, have a bad knee, but am generally in good shape. It hurts to walk several blocks, so I ride the scooter. I’ve ridden a road bike in traffic for 30 years so I know mostly how to ride defensively. I apply the same thought process to the scooters. I’ve ridden in Austin, Kansas City and Denver downtowns.  I see people riding them who have no clue however.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1005286

Man facing murder charge after California woman beaten with motorized scooter

May 14, 2019, 4:51 AM ET

By Phil Helsel

A man accused of beating a woman with a motorized scooter is facing a murder charge in her death.

Officers were called to the site of the attack, on a street in Long Beach, California, Monday afternoon, police said in a statement.

Rosa Elena Hernandez, 63, was killed in the attack.

"Detectives believe the suspect physically assaulted the victim and then proceeded to utilize a motorized scooter as a weapon during the assault," police said.

A little more than four hours later, police said they arrested a person of interest, who was booked on a murder charger and is being held in lieu of $2 million bail.

The suspect was not identified by police.

View this graphic on nbcnews.com

The attack appeared to have been random, NBC Los Angeles reported, citing police. Hernandez was walking down the street when a man began attacking her, police told the station.

NBC Los Angeles reported that the man used an electric scooter in the attack.

The Los Angeles Times reported that was a Bird scooter, and that authorities don't believe the attacker and victim knew each other.Bird scooters are dockless e-scooters available to rent.

Police said that the suspect fled on foot after the assault, and the person who was arrested was found at a local business.

Friends and family of Hernandez laid candles Monday night at the spot where she was killed.

"She was a nice lady, always said hi to everybody," neighbor Veronica Morales told NBC Los Angeles, adding that she was well known on the street. "Nobody deserves what that person did," Morales said.

Long Beach is a city on the coast south of Los Angeles.

Phil Helsel is a reporter for NBC News.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If we're going to continue to be a country of independently mobile individuals, that is favoring self propulsion (of sorts) to mass transportation then this is probably just a painful evolutionary step. We'll need to adapt. I wonder what the accident rates are like in countries where this type of transportation predominates. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/12/2019 at 3:41 PM, Lobo said:

I know that we're doubling down on our desire to not properly expand the roads.  But we've also cut a lot of safety corners along the way as well.  Something I was not so prepared to learn about, very troubling that's not just about ease of rush hour, but how some of our roads and intersections are much more dangerous than they need to be because of our desire to place capital resources elsewhere.  

Don't worry, they'll build a toll road to fix it. 😒

 

Also, i've ridden on one and simple common sense told me to be careful with it. People really are idiots who can't be trusted. But like anything else, with awareness it will improve over time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Auto Driller said:

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1005286

Man facing murder charge after California woman beaten with motorized scooter

May 14, 2019, 4:51 AM ET

By Phil Helsel

A man accused of beating a woman with a motorized scooter is facing a murder charge in her death.

Officers were called to the site of the attack, on a street in Long Beach, California, Monday afternoon, police said in a statement.

Rosa Elena Hernandez, 63, was killed in the attack.

"Detectives believe the suspect physically assaulted the victim and then proceeded to utilize a motorized scooter as a weapon during the assault," police said.

A little more than four hours later, police said they arrested a person of interest, who was booked on a murder charger and is being held in lieu of $2 million bail.

The suspect was not identified by police.

View this graphic on nbcnews.com

The attack appeared to have been random, NBC Los Angeles reported, citing police. Hernandez was walking down the street when a man began attacking her, police told the station.

NBC Los Angeles reported that the man used an electric scooter in the attack.

The Los Angeles Times reported that was a Bird scooter, and that authorities don't believe the attacker and victim knew each other.Bird scooters are dockless e-scooters available to rent.

Police said that the suspect fled on foot after the assault, and the person who was arrested was found at a local business.

Friends and family of Hernandez laid candles Monday night at the spot where she was killed.

"She was a nice lady, always said hi to everybody," neighbor Veronica Morales told NBC Los Angeles, adding that she was well known on the street. "Nobody deserves what that person did," Morales said.

Long Beach is a city on the coast south of Los Angeles.

Phil Helsel is a reporter for NBC News.

Bird's of a feather murder together. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, C-Man said:

When these things started popping up in downtown Dallas, I thought it was an interesting -- albeit potentially -- dangerous addition to getting around the city. I still haven't gotten up the courage to jump on one. At that time I went looking to see where you could ride them. I don't recall the details but it made it seem like you can't ride them on sidewalks in downtown Dallas or Deep Ellum and you also can't ride them on the street when the MPH was a certain speed or higher. I remember thinking that eliminated both streets and sidewalks in downtown/Deep Ellum but nobody is paying attention to those rules. My cousin's husband has started one of these companies in San Antonio.

I was riding between deep ellum and uptown and it was kind of a mix of using the sidewalk, bike lanes and the street. I was definitely cautious of riding in the actual street, though, mostly because there was almost always a sidewalk, partially because I didn't want to be in the flow of traffic.

In a city like Austin I'm guessing bike lanes should be well equipped to handle the scooter traffic.

@CycleTex87 I agree. Just don't ride like a fucking idiot and it isn't any more dangerous than a bike at all. 

@El Diablo Like SE Asia or Central America? I can't speak to accident rates but I know traffic laws are basically non existent in a lot of those countries. When I was in the Dominican Republic a lot of the locals rode dirt bikes or scooters with almost zero regard for safety. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 hours ago, ajax said:

The scooters don't belong on sidewalks. They shouldn't be on the road with cars either. There should be a network of dedicated lanes for these types of vehicles. 

But you don't get there magically. No city's going to build the infrastructure without a crisis to drive it. A few lanes here and there isn't enough to get people from A to B. Hence this clusterfuck is a necessary step. I hope it gets worse so we can build the damn thing.

Remember, the alternative is these people hailing Ubers and Lyfts, which has made traffic fuck-awful.

Why isn’t the alternative walking?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, ztejas said:

@El Diablo Like SE Asia or Central America? I can't speak to accident rates but I know traffic laws are basically non existent in a lot of those countries. When I was in the Dominican Republic a lot of the locals rode dirt bikes or scooters with almost zero regard for safety. 

Yes, like SE Asia, some areas of Europe and Central/South America. It does appear that there are no traffic laws as such and yet they seem to manage. I suspect that most of those folks have their heads on swivels and are infinitely more aware of their surroundings than the average American driver. What appears as chaos to you may not be to them.We're a country that wants to use cruise control, text, etc... all at the same time. I think it will take a cultural shift in attitudes about what constitutes responsible driving  and a greater appreciation for physics to make the transition.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, ztejas said:

Just don't ride like a fucking idiot

All available data indicates that this is effectively impossible.  The number of scooter riders I see who AREN'T 1) running traffic signals, 2) weaving in and out of traffic, 3) damned near running down pedestrian after pedestrian is so miniscule as to not be worth mentioning.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Brisketexan said:

All available data indicates that this is effectively impossible.  The number of scooter riders I see who AREN'T 1) running traffic signals, 2) weaving in and out of traffic, 3) damned near running down pedestrian after pedestrian is so miniscule as to not be worth mentioning.

This is the correct answer.  The scooters are fine. Nothing wrong with them at all and they present an affordable, convenient means of short track transportation.  

 

The problem is, 85% of the American public is full on regard.  

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Brisketexan said:

All available data indicates that this is effectively impossible.  The number of scooter riders I see who AREN'T 1) running traffic signals, 2) weaving in and out of traffic, 3) damned near running down pedestrian after pedestrian is so miniscule as to not be worth mentioning.

Well, it's impossible with everything else that is self-operated, too. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...