Jump to content

dcar00

Legacy Members
  • Posts

    39395
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by dcar00

  1. auto bids are different. they also said if you make the conf champ game you very likely don't get punished. one of the reasons SMU made it over Bama last year plus "surprise" loss column SMU 2/bama 3. we are discussing number of losses before the CC games. they also can't really consider CC games much because "another surprise!"...Notre Dame doesn't have a 13th data point for you old schoolers(aka a CC).
  2. if those are our only losses we are in, if we play Wisconsin or Vriginia Tech, etc. we did beat the pants off of a playoff team as well.
  3. IMO, we'd be 8/9 with win against a decent P4 team but would still need to beat aggy and would then be guaranteed in.
  4. the bold is why they sprinkle in the 1 loss/2 loss non SEC/Big 12 to cover for the SOR. the group loss the SEC/Big Ten Tech at 5 should be a red flag but hidden by the fact that 1-4 are Big Ten/SEC. I would submit Indiana at 4 is a yellow flag given their SOS at 49 and OOC of ODU, Kennesaw, Indiana St, but tOSU's is 46
  5. Florida is not good and it was a bad loss but they also have the #1 SOS. hell they aimost beat and got fucked against Georgia AFTER their coach got fired. since we like to talk about bad wins like Kentucky and MSU. I do agree they totally gave up after the loss to UGA.
  6. it is about the number in the loss column. I bet if you take a neutral site Tech, BYU, Utah, Vandy, OU, Mich are not favored. Bama would be a slight favorite, IMO. not sure on that because it is a huge rivalry for them but we'd be favored, neutral site.
  7. I think they mainly changed conf champ get bye's to top 4 overall get bye's not because of what happened with us as the 5 but because AD's were saying what is the advantage to scheduling big time OOC game if I only get a bye by winning the conf. now there is a small chance winning a big time OOC game gets you a bye but if they just rank by loss column what is the point. Tech at 5 is a good indicator. they are #5 with one loss to #20 ASU. they played a 2-9 Pac 12 left behind Oregon State, have a SOS of 70, yet they are #5 because they only have a 1 in the loss column. I could make a case they should be just ahead of Bama or even behind Bama with the #6 SOS. it is about the loss column and it always will be.
  8. well of course there is reality/data/logic as to the best path to make the playoff and then there is "PUSSY!"
  9. what is the "loss column"? Alex
  10. maybe, depends on if your coach wants to practice or not.
  11. if you want the best chance to get into the tournament on average yes. I would submit that I'd like our coach/OC/QB whisperer to have an actual real OL coach and build a real OL and make sure our 3 year in the program 5 star QB is ready to go.
  12. H2H only matters if you have the same number of losses. it does matter a lot more than SOS when there is same number of losses. top 12 or top 25 wins matter very little. "deserves" got nothin to do with it...
  13. I don't think anyone is saying it is a travesty if we don't get in. we have 3 losses.
  14. they will never not rank by losses. they even fixed the Texas Michigan issue they had mistakenly set themselves up for because of it. anyway, we took the 3rd loss and so we are out. it is funny aggy bitched enough that they will not have Bama and UGA in the same season ever. always next year. wonder what happens if heisman finalist Mateer has a season ending injury?
  15. all games count. I would vote for 10 conf games and 2 OOC.
  16. exactly. lets get rid of most of the beauty contest and just say 3 losses you are out. we will pick the best 8 from the rest, no auto bid and the champ game of your conference actually counts
  17. I was on board with the 8 team 25 years ago with the 12 team conferences. play 10 conf games and 2 OOC. the superconferences screwed this all up because you can game the system with the schedule(see aggy this year). 2027 and 2029 we have UGA, Bama, ND. sure we could win 3 of those but could lose all 3. meanwhile Tech with the 70th ranked schedule and loses to Arizona fucking State. is in. they didn't beat all the teams they should beat. Utah with the 50th ranked schedule and 2 losses is ahead of us. even aggy's schedule is 15 or something while playing the dregs of the SEC and ND. Ole Miss played no one OOC and almost lost at home to Wazzu, should have lost to LSU and possibly the same Ark team we drilled. they should just say the cut line is fewer than 3 losses and we'll pick the best 8 from there. then everyone knows the score. our SOS will always be good enough with a decent P4 and 2 others and there will always be arguments. we are out with 3 losses no matter what, as was Bama last year, due to the necessity for the committee to include other Big 12 and ACC teams and even a 2 loss ND(with a 27th SOS this year) in the mix. G5 just makes it worse. G5 can get fucked at this point, IMO. they can have their own 8 team playoff. maybe these last 2 years are outliers but I'll believe it when I see it that a 3 loss non conf champ makes the top 11 in the super conference era because they rank by number of losses. don't lose 3 games regardless of who they are to.
  18. then we should go to top 4 teams regardless of conference.
  19. our D is certainly not peaking. having smith out in the 1H isn't going to help.
  20. I dont think anyone knows how good aggy is they played the bottom half of the SEC and ND.
  21. yep. we couldn't afford a 3rd loss and the Florida game was the easiest of the 3 to win.
  22. not a chance. MIch lost to the only 2 good teams on their schedule and only one of those is in the playoff. they had to fix it for the loss column just in case the world burns.
  23. right, we are talking if OU or Bama or both loses.
  24. loss column so that if chaos happens all over the place and Mich beats OSU and we beat aggy. Mich goes. they had to fix that from last week.
×
×
  • Create New...