Haven't seen much of the team this year, but if it's true that Arch is just missing wide open receivers and throwing the ball at their feat against UTEP, that's a massive red flag. You can explain away a poor performance in the horseshoe, but a guy in his 3rd year on campus should not be this bad against UTEP. If every other qb on the roster is really 10-straight-incompletions-against-UTEP bad then Sark is stealing money from the University. I don't want to believe Sark is actually that incompetent, so I have to assume he's being stubborn leaving Arch out there.
If the defense is still elite then I say we roll with Caldwell and hope he can be an average, functional, college qb. Can't let Arch dick around against another cupcake and then try to throw someone else into the fire in conference play if Arch sucks it up again. Beat OU, Arky, and Aggy and ideally don't lose to anyone except Georgia and I'd consider this season a success at this point, because based on what I've heard, I'm fearing a 2010 level collapse.