Jump to content

Arch Manning: Doing his best JAG impression to fool scouts


Recommended Posts

Posted

Arch & Quinn are so different that trying to compare them is practically folly.  Arch is slow on his reads, doesn't check down well, and has relatively poor touch and accuracy in the short game.  He also has an instinct to step up and stand tall in the pocket, and is tough enough to take big hits.  Quinn was much quicker in his reads and check downs, had fantastic touch and accuracy and the short game, but he self sacked over and over again.  He was worse on the deep throws than Arch, but neither has shown themselves to be great in that regard.

Arch has wheels, Quinn had snowshoes.  That might be the biggest differentiator.  At least one dude can manufacture yards.  I guess I'll take Arch, given that there might be some upside to come.

  • Hook 'Em 1
Posted (edited)
28 minutes ago, Derka said:

what a shocker it is that the guy who rated quinn ewers a 10/10 every single game is now coming down hard on arch manning when the o line was undisputedly the story of the day, a day in which arch routinely made the exact type of plays that QE was never able to make during three years as a starter, standing tall in the pocket, taking hits, extending plays with his legs, making plays downfield, etc. i’m just floored at this development i tell you. total shocker.

Anytime I find my opinion in opposition with Derka about football, I know I am on the correct track. 

Everyone here knows the O-line sucks Derka. What I am saying is Arch is making it worse. I give you, granted sometimes rushed, but legit football takes. You are in here with feelings and vibes. No factual anything. I have respect for guys like Codaxx and others. We may arrive at different opinions, but at least I know they can see the game. 

And NOBODY said QE was a 10/10. I simply KNEW he was better than Arch, not as bad as you said he was, and our best option last year. Move the goalposts some more. 

Edited by Thatguy
Posted
4 minutes ago, BurntOrange&White said:

So answer this what have you see from arch THIS YEAR that gives you confidence in him and makes you think he’s a better QB than Quinn

listen you combative fucking mongoloid, i have not only repeatedly said that arch has been bad this year, i have repeatedly stated that he’s *not* better than quinn was, and yet your combative, juvenile ass is still in here yelling at me for saying that arch is awesome when i’ve said nothing of the sort.

arch stood tall in the pocket under constant pressure and took a beating while still making throws downfield- quinn couldn’t do that. arch scrambled when under pressure and then made plays downfield- quinn couldn’t do that. arch can be worse than quinn was and still be able to do things that quinn couldn’t do. i know that level of adult thinking escapes you, so you’re going to have to take my word for it.

my stance on all of this is crystal clear, and there’s nothing in this post that i haven’t already said. you room temperature iq having motherfuckers who are so tribalistic about this shit are the worst. you think that everyone is either on team quinn or team arch, so all you do is talk shit and try to “own” people or “win” the argument. i have no idea why people put up with your shit and don’t neg you into bolivia, but you post like a 12 year old who needs attention and you should be embarrassed as you must certainly be in your 40’s by now. you’re a stain on this thread and this board. grow the fuck up.

Posted
2 minutes ago, Derka said:

listen you combative fucking mongoloid, i have not only repeatedly said that arch has been bad this year, i have repeatedly stated that he’s *not* better than quinn was, and yet your combative, juvenile ass is still in here yelling at me for saying that arch is awesome when i’ve said nothing of the sort.

arch stood tall in the pocket under constant pressure and took a beating while still making throws downfield- quinn couldn’t do that. arch scrambled when under pressure and then made plays downfield- quinn couldn’t do that. arch can be worse than quinn was and still be able to do things that quinn couldn’t do. i know that level of adult thinking escapes you, so you’re going to have to take my word for it.

my stance on all of this is crystal clear, and there’s nothing in this post that i haven’t already said. you room temperature iq having motherfuckers who are so tribalistic about this shit are the worst. you think that everyone is either on team quinn or team arch, so all you do is talk shit and try to “own” people or “win” the argument. i have no idea why people put up with your shit and don’t neg you into bolivia, but you post like a 12 year old who needs attention and you should be embarrassed as you must certainly be in your 40’s by now. you’re a stain on this thread and this board. grow the fuck up.

Good now stfu 

  • Haha 1
Posted
2 minutes ago, Derka said:

listen you combative fucking mongoloid, i have not only repeatedly said that arch has been bad this year, i have repeatedly stated that he’s *not* better than quinn was, and yet your combative, juvenile ass is still in here yelling at me for saying that arch is awesome when i’ve said nothing of the sort.

arch stood tall in the pocket under constant pressure and took a beating while still making throws downfield- quinn couldn’t do that. arch scrambled when under pressure and then made plays downfield- quinn couldn’t do that. arch can be worse than quinn was and still be able to do things that quinn couldn’t do. i know that level of adult thinking escapes you, so you’re going to have to take my word for it.

my stance on all of this is crystal clear, and there’s nothing in this post that i haven’t already said. you room temperature iq having motherfuckers who are so tribalistic about this shit are the worst. you think that everyone is either on team quinn or team arch, so all you do is talk shit and try to “own” people or “win” the argument. i have no idea why people put up with your shit and don’t neg you into bolivia, but you post like a 12 year old who needs attention and you should be embarrassed as you must certainly be in your 40’s by now. you’re a stain on this thread and this board. grow the fuck up.

zero anything really about football. all vibes and feelings. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...