I don't disagree, but this message from Talarico:
Is essentially saying "I want to reconcile with my countrymen who I might disagree with politically so we can find a path forward together" But it's coming from a Democratic Party member in a deeply red state, and Democrats are at their lowest point of appeal, power and influence in my lifetime. So it seems pretty disingenuous and self serving coming from a member of the party that is, from what I can tell, on life support while the other party has a hand on the power cord. Add into that the decades of conditioning that all things left, liberal and with a D attached to it are evil, and Talarico the Democrat isn't going to pull any meaningful number of voters from the right with that message at this stage of our devolution.
For that idea to be embraceable by people who have been voting right, it's going to have to come from someone not on the left. And for that idea to be embraceable by people who have been voting left, it's going to have to come from someone not on the right. Maybe someone like Arnold Schwarzenegger (Republican, demonstrably not MAGA) could form a new party around that idea and get people to buy into it. But, I dunno.