I have so many issues with this season.
1. As mentioned about Scar Island/the Aquarium. I fucking hate when TV/Movies use a literal place (like Seattle) and then fuck up the geography. Plus, even if Ellie washes up on an island in that kind of weather, she's probably dead. The closest island to Pier 59 is Bainbridge and that's 10 miles away. Plus, haven't the Scars eschewed technology? So how are they way the fuck over there and then getting over to Seattle proper? And why are they even doing so? Seems like staying on Bainbridge and not dealing with the WLF at all would be the best course of action. Finally, Isaac's boat come out the south and head north to wherever their going. The closest heavily wooded area on the water going north would be Discovery Park and that's 8+ miles away. So the Scar's are basecamping 7-8 miles north of downtown? That's 2-4 hours of walking. Ellie, Dina and Jesse "escape" into a park after Jesse finds them. WTF?
2. Item two on the Aquariam. The land where the Aquariam sits is about 400-500 feet from a very, very large incline/hill @ Western Avenue. The show has the Aquariam way the fuck out in Elliott Bay. If the area between the Aquariam and Alaskan Way/Western Avenue was under water, then the Aquarium and Wheel are under water as well.
3. The WLF have set up at Lumen Field. That could explain why Isaac's Navy came from the south. But that puts Discovery Park close to 10 miles north. Those little boats are going that far in that weather? Which bring me to...
4. Where the fuck are the WLF getting gasoline from? According to the game, it's been 25 years since the outbreak. Even if it had only been 5 years, gas isn't going to do shit. Seattle isn't exactly known for it's oil fields and refineries.
5. When Joel send Ellie back to get the horses. They left them on top of the hill because the switchbacks would take too long to get down. They thought they had an hour or two before Eugene changed. Ellie had time to get back up those switchbacks and then down? While leading another horse that would take even more time? Their initial descent would have taken 10-15 minutes minimum. By the time they found Eugene he was already a dead man. He wasn't making it back to Jackson.
6. I realize it's an integral part of the whole story line but Ellie's thirst for revenge just keeps getting people killed.
I realize I am arguing points about a TV show where mushrooms have infected people but still.
Final thought from earlier in the season. Who the fuck thought it was a good idea to use flamethrowers in a town surrouned by a wooden fence? And who thought an all wood fence was the best idea? I realize Jackson wouldn't exactly have foundry to make steel plates but there had to be a better solution.