This is how I feel about it.
Williams is a diva. Who knows if some of the Twitter shit is true but tweets say he doesn’t want to be drafted by Chicago and was a share of whatever team drafts him. Has the tools to be good but will his ego let him?
Maye just isn’t crazy impressive to me. 21-9 as a starter, no ACC champs (played in 1, a 39-10 loss to Clemson where we went 26/42 for 264, 0 TDs and 2 INTs), no playoff appearances, no NY6 appearances. An article I read said the ceiling for him is Carson Palmer and the floor is Blake Bortles.
Nix and Penix fall into kinda the same category for me in the sense of both weren’t top 10 pick level of QB until these last two seasons where both were a 22 and 23 year old multi year starter. Nix was dogshit till he got to Oregon and Penix obviously has the injury history.
Daniels is the wildcard for me. He’s had 3 years of improved throwing accuracy, passing yards, TDs and INTs. His rushing also improved year by year. Doesn’t have any injuries to really note. He’s hard to compare to someone NFL wise. He’s not the thrower that Watson was coming out but he’s a better runner whereas he’s a much more polished passer than Lamar was but not the runner (Lamar is a lazy comparison to me, I look more Justin Fields/Kyler Murray outta college). We’ve seen where Fields and Murray stand as far as the NFL is concerned.
JJ isn’t good. He’s got nearly identical stats as Greg McElroy coming out of Bama.
I think best case scenario for everyone is Williams and Daniels are stars, Penix is a serviceable starter, Nix and Maye are fringe starter types and JJ is a career backup.