Technically, we are down the line a bit due to being such a latecomer to the sport, but in terms of 21st century recency, yes - it's OKST, Oregon, Tennessee, Texas as the best programs to not win one in this millennium. No offense to those small schools who went a bunch of times in the 70s and 80s.
Last trip in parenthesis
OKST (2024) - 0 titles in 16 trips
Northern Colorado (1979) - 0 titles in 11 trips
South Carolina (1997) - 0 titles in 11 trips
Nebraska (2013), Tennessee (2025), Oregon (2025) - 0 titles in 9 trips
Illinois State (1981), Western Illinois (1982), Texas (2025), - 0 titles in 8 trips
Missouri (2011), Cal Poly Pomona (1989), Kansas (1992) - 0 titles in 7 trips
Texas and Tenn both have 2 appearances in the finals with no titles. OKST has only been once. Oregon, Nebraska, South Carolina have never made the finals.
Texas is the best program in recent history without a title - 2 trips in the last 3 years without a title. If it wasn't for 2018, FSU would be up there too. They went to the finals in 2018, 2021, 2023