Jump to content

Some basic probabilities help


Recommended Posts

My son is taking an online math class at Sam and some of the probabilities problems are giving him issues.   This is not my forte and it's due tonight.  He's done about 16 so far, but still has two left.  Any help would be much appreciated.  

I am going to post screenshots of the problems, so you can see exactly how the problems are worded.  

The first one on the lottery I asked him if he could work it backwards using the formula he used to get the -$4.99, but the question is what are they after for fair game?  break even?  Set the value to $0 or $5.00?   

math6.thumb.png.0883ce43fda5f06b977ab3535fdd498c.png

 

Here's the second one.  Maybe we have looked at it too long.  I mean it's possible that no hands in any one deal would have two hearts and two clubs.   And actually the question should read "contain" exactly, not "consist".    No 7 card hand can consist solely of 4 cards.   It can contain specific types of cards and still be 7 cards.  Probably reading too much into it.   Thanks folks.   math7.thumb.png.19b7877ea2c8f0bf2cb8d5775e7e45bb.png

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Huckleberry said:

 

Lotteries are, generally speaking, combination problems versus permutations because in combinations order does not matter. So you're looking for the number of combinations of 7 items selected from 65. 

image.png.1571bb16a4dae3849a2c27913e729c71.png

So there are 696,190,560 possible lottery results. Expected value is [(696,190,559*-5) + (1*9,699,995)] / 696,190,560 = -$4.986 which rounds to -$4.99

I used $9,699,995 instead of $9,700,000 for the winning possibility because you don't get your $5 back with most lotteries.

To determine the fair game payout value you set the EV equal to zero. So we have

 [(696,190,559*-5) + (1*(x-5))] / 696,190,560 = 0

(696,190,559*-5) + (1*(x-5)) = 0

1*(x-5) = 696,190,559*5

x-5 = 3,480,952,795

x = 3,480,952,800

The real problem here is if the teacher/website are going to use x or x-5 for their answer. To me the correct answer is as I show above. They might have the value without the 5 added as the answer though if they're not accounting for losing the 5 dollars when you win the payout.

Yeah you're right about how it's phrased but you know what they're looking for. Shorthand notation is C(13,2) x C(13,2) x C(26,3) equals 78 x 78 x 2600 = 15,818,400 hands that will have 2 hearts and 2 clubs. Basically the number of ways you can get 2 of the 13 hearts times the number of ways you can get 2 of the 13 clubs times the number of ways you can get 3 of the 26 spades and diamonds. All three of those things have to happen so you need to multiply the number of possible events of each of them to get your total number of possibilities. This comes out to roughly 11.8% of all 7-card hands which passes the smell test. 

 

ice-cube-wtf.gif

  • Hook 'Em 1
  • Haha 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 hours ago, Huckleberry said:

The real problem here is if the teacher/website are going to use x or x-5 for their answer. To me the correct answer is as I show above. They might have the value without the 5 added as the answer though if they're not accounting for losing the 5 dollars when you win the payout.

It's easier if you think of it as expected return against cost.  The expected return is the jackpot times the probability of winning, or $9,700,000 * 1/696,190,560 = 0.01393297.  Your cost is $5.  Expected return - Cost = -$4.98606703.  A fair game would have the expected return equal the cost.   Jackpot * 1/696,190,560 = $5.  Jackpot must equal $3,480,952,800 for the expected return to equal the cost.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 12/1/2021 at 6:27 PM, Huckleberry said:

 

Lotteries are, generally speaking, combination problems versus permutations because in combinations order does not matter. So you're looking for the number of combinations of 7 items selected from 65. 

image.png.1571bb16a4dae3849a2c27913e729c71.png

So there are 696,190,560 possible lottery results. Expected value is [(696,190,559*-5) + (1*9,699,995)] / 696,190,560 = -$4.986 which rounds to -$4.99

I used $9,699,995 instead of $9,700,000 for the winning possibility because you don't get your $5 back with most lotteries.

To determine the fair game payout value you set the EV equal to zero. So we have

 [(696,190,559*-5) + (1*(x-5))] / 696,190,560 = 0

(696,190,559*-5) + (1*(x-5)) = 0

1*(x-5) = 696,190,559*5

x-5 = 3,480,952,795

x = 3,480,952,800

The real problem here is if the teacher/website are going to use x or x-5 for their answer. To me the correct answer is as I show above. They might have the value without the 5 added as the answer though if they're not accounting for losing the 5 dollars when you win the payout.

Yeah you're right about how it's phrased but you know what they're looking for. Shorthand notation is C(13,2) x C(13,2) x C(26,3) equals 78 x 78 x 2600 = 15,818,400 hands that will have 2 hearts and 2 clubs. Basically the number of ways you can get 2 of the 13 hearts times the number of ways you can get 2 of the 13 clubs times the number of ways you can get 3 of the 26 spades and diamonds. All three of those things have to happen so you need to multiply the number of possible events of each of them to get your total number of possibilities. This comes out to roughly 11.8% of all 7-card hands which passes the smell test. 

 

 

32D470D2-57EB-4036-ADCA-04CAC3C1E81A.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...