Jump to content

So I got a WSM...


thunderlounge

Recommended Posts

So...My first brisket was a little dry. Nice flavor but I definitely left it on too long.  Chopped it up and made some chili.

One of the potential issues was that my Smoke ambient temperature probe was running about 25 degrees HIGHER than the WSM lid thermometer. I expected the opposite and wasn't quite sure how to deal with it so I ended up adjusting things way to much toward the end.   The probe was on the top grate about 2 inches from the brisket. 

Thoughts?

I have the 22.5 .  Also, I filled that grate to the top using Minion method and never had to add anything.  According to the lid thermometer, it was hitting 275 at 15 hours. 

Edited by Chico_SA
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yup I was trying to strike a balance between my wife’s preference of, at most, medium to medium-well and my medium-rare to medium. I was aiming for a medium cooked meat and had probed right at that level but, as you can see, it overshot and ended up being well done instead. Still, as I said before and to refute some of you Uber BBQ dorks, it was still pretty tasty.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So...My first brisket was a little dry. Nice flavor but I definitely left it on too long.  Chopped it up and made some chili.
One of the potential issues was that my Smoke ambient temperature probe was running about 25 degrees HIGHER than the WSM lid thermometer. I expected the opposite and wasn't quite sure how to deal with it so I ended up adjusting things way to much toward the end.   The probe was on the top grate about 2 inches from the brisket. 
Thoughts?
I have the 22.5 .  Also, I filled that grate to the top using Minion method and never had to add anything.  According to the lid thermometer, it was hitting 275 at 15 hours. 
How close to the edge was your probe? Too close to the edge and it will read high as a result of the gap between the water pan and the edge. Your assumption is correct. Lid should read hotter than either grate.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

51 minutes ago, dcbc said:
13 hours ago, Chico_SA said:

 

How close to the edge was your probe? Too close to the edge and it will read high as a result of the gap between the water pan and the edge. Your assumption is correct. Lid should read hotter than either grate.

My lid always runs 20-25 degrees lower than the probe. I always assumed it was mainly because the lid gauge sucks ass.

Edited by TornACL
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, thunderlounge said:

I don’t care a out, nor pay attention to the lid temp. 

This is the real takeaway.

Mine runs hotter and the consensus on virtual bullet is that that is the case, but it's a ymmv situation since those lid thermometers are worthless.

 

http://virtualweberbullet.com/measuretemp.html

Edited by dcbc
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

the lid gauge is consistent but not accurate. i've never used an additional probe on the grate, the lid gauge lets me know if the temp is consistent, that's all that matters. if my lid gauge is sitting between 225-250 i've never had a problem. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, dcbc said:

This is the real takeaway.

Mine runs hotter and the consensus on virtual bullet is that that is the case, but it's a ymmv situation since those lid thermometers are worthless.

 

http://virtualweberbullet.com/measuretemp.html

And that is what I expected.  I''ll probably do another this weekend so I'll compare. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, mdleast said:

Yup I was trying to strike a balance between my wife’s preference of, at most, medium to medium-well and my medium-rare to medium. I was aiming for a medium cooked meat and had probed right at that level but, as you can see, it overshot and ended up being well done instead. Still, as I said before and to refute some of you Uber BBQ dorks, it was still pretty tasty.

Looks tasty.  How did you cook it?  Low and slow or hot and fast?  Smoked or just grilled? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did the hot and fast cook recipe from the Weber Virtual Bullet website. Only in the smoker for a max of 45-50 minutes. Think that’s the main reason I ended up with well cooked meat (also my porn star name). While I pulled it to sear for 5 minutes right when it was probing as “medium” I think the 5 minutes of searing and 10 minutes rest gave it time to then move up to well done status. Still tasty at well done but not what I normally shoot for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I asked about this on TOS and have been looking for it for a while, but it seemed like it either didn't exist or was more than I wanted to pay.

What I wanted was a temperature probe setup that linked up to the wifi so I could monitor pit and meat temps remotely, or, at the least, wouldn't be limited in range by Bluetooth.

On Thursday, I was at WalMart and went to the grilling area to grab some charcoal.  While I was there, I noticed a $24 "WiFi" probe by "ProGrade."  I grabbed it just to see if it was worth a damn.  It's only got one probe and I'm running a Maverick dual probe monitor closer to the pit.  But since I have two briskets going, I stick this probe into one of them and downloaded the app.  It's bare bones, but it works like a charm.  The puck is rechargeable via USB and has been going for 13 hours now.  Not sure if I have the alarm setup correctly, but we shall see.  In the future, I might run the pit temp probe to it instead.  Pretty excited  about this cheap find.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Mojo Hand said:

How's the thermaworks smoke system compared to the Maverick?  Is that where those charts of smoking progress I've seen here are from? 

What is it that you're looking for that you're not getting from the Maverick.  I was messing around with the cheapo wifi probe I got this week and it appears to have a temp chart screen buried somewhere in the app.  So far, other than range, the Maverick dual temp probe/receiver has worked well for me.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 minutes ago, dcbc said:

What is it that you're looking for that you're not getting from the Maverick.  I was messing around with the cheapo wifi probe I got this week and it appears to have a temp chart screen buried somewhere in the app.  So far, other than range, the Maverick dual temp probe/receiver has worked well for me.

Range, mostly.  But I also like those charts. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Charts? Hell, my iGrill does charts, and across 4 probes. Bluetooth of course, so I set my tablet up and leave it. The range is ok, but not great. Maverick was a little better.

Wi-fi on the iGrill would be tits, as that's my only bitch about it really. (Well, that and I can't set a meat temp alert higher than 200*, thanks to a recent update. Work around is setting a temp range instead. The 4 probes come in pretty fucking handy from time to time though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wifi really is the ideal connection, and it apparently can be done for cheap and with plenty of battery life left over based on the POS I bought that worked flawlessly.  Just wish it was dual probe, but that's not a deal breaker.  It's pretty much the gold standard for range. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyone here built or bought a charcoal basket for their WSM?  A 13 lb bag of charcoal will get me 12 hours on my WSM.  It's easy enough to add more, but it seems like it would be pretty cheap to get a #9 expanded metal basket welded up the same diameter as the charcoal ring, but at twice the height so that once I have it going, I don't have to mess with the fuel again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, dcbc said:

Anyone here built or bought a charcoal basket for their WSM?  A 13 lb bag of charcoal will get me 12 hours on my WSM.  It's easy enough to add more, but it seems like it would be pretty cheap to get a #9 expanded metal basket welded up the same diameter as the charcoal ring, but at twice the height so that once I have it going, I don't have to mess with the fuel again.

Wouldn't the water pan get in the way?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, dcbc said:

I think there's some clearance under there.

I don't think there's that much. I've only used an 18.5" but I've had some conflicts with a pile of charcoal/wood chunks and the water pan before. If you doubled the height of the fire ring on an 18.5" then i don't think the water pan would fit. Maybe the 22" is different. I don't know which one you have. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, WhatTheBuck said:

I don't think there's that much. I've only used an 18.5" but I've had some conflicts with a pile of charcoal/wood chunks and the water pan before. If you doubled the height of the fire ring on an 18.5" then i don't think the water pan would fit. Maybe the 22" is different. I don't know which one you have. 

There's a lot of room on the 22".  The link below is for a stainless basket for the 22.  It comes with a grate.  It's not cheap, but it's also $45 to ship, which makes it a tougher sell.  It's overkill, but it looks nice.  It's 8" tall (comes up to the edge of the lower portion of the WSM) and holds 37 lbs of charcoal. 

7_Jx_SCSx_WBH9t_CLx_Ba_FB1dfwq_VRNWXru_I

 

http://arborfab.com/Charcoal-Ring-for-Weber-Smokey-Mountain-Grill-185-225_p_127.html

Edited by dcbc
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, dcbc said:

There's a lot of room on the 22".  The link below is for a stainless basket for the 22.  It comes with a grate.  It's not cheap, but it's also $45 to ship, which makes it a tougher sell.  It's overkill, but it looks nice.  It's 8" tall (comes up to the edge of the lower portion of the WSM) and holds 37 lbs of charcoal. 

7_Jx_SCSx_WBH9t_CLx_Ba_FB1dfwq_VRNWXru_I

 

http://arborfab.com/Charcoal-Ring-for-Weber-Smokey-Mountain-Grill-185-225_p_127.html

Yeah, I was thinking back to episodes of Steven Raichlen's shows that I've seen and I recalled the water pan on the 22" being much shallower than on the 18.5".  On the 18.5" it's roughly hemispherical. It's fairly deep.

Fwiw, I haven't found it to be any problem when the coals are really close to or in contact with the water pan. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I’m curious as to how you’re eating so much charcoal. A full bag of blue and I’m good to go. I prefer stubbs, which is a little smaller bag, but rarely need more than a bag of that either  

The only times I’ve really needed more has been if it’s windy. By the time it needed more, I just added a few good handfuls, which was about a chimneys worth in volume. Of course stuff was wrapped by then, so a little ash in the air didn’t matter. 

I haven’t had that problem since building the shack, and wind now has zero effect on fuel consumption. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, WhatTheBuck said:

Yeah, I was thinking back to episodes of Steven Raichlen's shows that I've seen and I recalled the water pan on the 22" being much shallower than on the 18.5".  On the 18.5" it's roughly hemispherical. It's fairly deep.

Fwiw, I haven't found it to be any problem when the coals are really close to or in contact with the water pan. 

My understanding is that they increased the size of the pan on the 22" at some point.  I've only owned it for about 9 months.  So I figure this is the larger version.  In any event, I don't think that basket is going to get things too close if it is an issue. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, thunderlounge said:

I’m curious as to how you’re eating so much charcoal. A full bag of blue and I’m good to go. I prefer stubbs, which is a little smaller bag, but rarely need more than a bag of that either  

The only times I’ve really needed more has been if it’s windy. By the time it needed more, I just added a few good handfuls, which was about a chimneys worth in volume. Of course stuff was wrapped by then, so a little ash in the air didn’t matter. 

I haven’t had that problem since building the shack, and wind now has zero effect on fuel consumption. 

 I run mine on our covered porch.  I have a ceiling fan going just to keep the smoke from getting bad in the area.  I don't think that's effecting much at the intake point. 

A full back of Kingsford fills up the charcoal ring on the 22" WSM.  I add a few fist sized wood chunks and light it off with about 10--12 hot coals in the center.  At the 12 hour point, the temp starts to drop off and I have to add some more charcoal.  When I'm at temp, I'm running the lid exhaust vent wide open.  I have two intake vents closed off and one open only about 1/3 of the way.  It holds temp very consistently.  Fuel consumption is consistent, too. 

Edited by dcbc
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wild. I’ll start 25-30 lit, and run 250ish, and wrap with paper at about 150-155. Typically have 2 vents craked open once to temp, 3rd is pretty much permanently closed. Top vent always full open. 

Kind of interesting how each one is just slightly different on the specifics, but overall characteristics remain constant. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, thunderlounge said:

Wild. I’ll start 25-30 lit, and run 250ish, and wrap with paper at about 150-155. Typically have 2 vents craked open once to temp, 3rd is pretty much permanently closed. Top vent always full open. 

Kind of interesting how each one is just slightly different on the specifics, but overall characteristics remain constant. 

For sure.  I don't really care about having to use a little extra charcoal as long as the temperature is easy to maintain.  Mine leaks at the lid a bit, and I think a gasket may be in order there.  But the rest of it seals up well ever since I got that Cajun Bandit Door. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, dcbc said:

For sure.  I don't really care about having to use a little extra charcoal as long as the temperature is easy to maintain.  Mine leaks at the lid a bit, and I think a gasket may be in order there.  But the rest of it seals up well ever since I got that Cajun Bandit Door. 

The lid gasket is totally worth it

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, dcbc said:

For sure.  I don't really care about having to use a little extra charcoal as long as the temperature is easy to maintain.  Mine leaks at the lid a bit, and I think a gasket may be in order there.  But the rest of it seals up well ever since I got that Cajun Bandit Door. 

I haven’t done anything to mine yet. Shit, the grommet for probes was toast early last year, and I haven’t replaced it yet. Only difference is the shack. I’m thinking about building a 3-sided break out of some scrap plywood I have laying around, just to see if that works as well. The shack is great, but all the heat cycles do take their toll. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I tried to do a gasket around my OEM door, but it was hit and miss.  I'll order some more and do the lid at some point. Mine's probably a bit out of round.  I'd do the bear hug thing, but my door seals so well, I figure why mess that up.

Also, I recently started using 2 clay pot bases in my pan instead of water.  Much easier to control temperature, but it may have extended cooking times and fuel usage. 

Edited by dcbc
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, thunderlounge said:

I use water for 250 or less. 275+ and I do without. I quit foiling the pan, and instead just foil the bottom rack. Cleanup is way easier, and no greasy water. 

I switched to two clay pot bases in the foiled pan.  Temperature has never been so easy to dial in.  Water was a pain for me since there's no hose bib close.  I don't think the moisture factor makes much of a difference.  But the main reason I switched is that a 3/4 full water pan would boil off over the length of the cook and as it did, temperature crept up.  With the clay pot bases, the heat sink effectiveness isn't a moving target.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

38 minutes ago, baboso said:

dcbc, Cajun Bandit sells a larger charcoal ring that allows you to put more fuel in.  Check it out.

That's right.  I forgot they had one.  I'll give it a look. 

Edited by dcbc
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Looks like the CB ring is the same height and only about 1.25" wider in diameter.  I think I'll keep my eye out for something bigger or just have something welded up locally.  In the meantime, I've ordered a gasket kit for the lid and am going to see how much charcoal I can cram into the stock ring since I have seen videos where people are pouring 21 lb bags into them.

Edited by dcbc
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...