Jump to content

Afghan War ending, foretold by The Onion 10 years Ago [DT thread ruined by politics]


crash_davis

Recommended Posts

9 minutes ago, WhatTheBuck said:

Except when he ignored Afghanistan after the Russians left and allowed the Taliban to take over in the first place.


Screw your imperial hubris. There was nothing he could have done that would have been acceptable to the American people at that time to prevent them from taking over. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, Hornius Emeritus said:


I am on record on Hornfans as saying before we invaded that it was going to be a bloody, costly mistake.  Then my cousin was very nearly killed in Baghdad by a RPG in 2004. Three years later, the young man who saved my cousin's life was killed by a roadside bomb.

I refuse to own this. 

 

C8C7A3EA-BEE1-4BC1-8D24-2CB428F8B380.gif

  • Hook 'Em 1
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Hornius Emeritus said:

imperial hubris.

Charlie Wilson disagrees. We washed our hands and walked away.

Interesting choice of words, though. Have you read the book by that title? That was my doorway into a whole lot of reading about the second Bush administration and the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.

3c56fa2b-bcf4-43fa-b476-0869ac65274d_1.c

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Aqua Buddha said:

I like how this is Bush’s war that Trump promised to exit but didn’t and it’s Joe Biden’s fault for doing it wrong.

Republicans acting like this exit would have been smoother and less awful under Trump are deluding themselves.   The Taliban was going to take over if we left 10 years ago, on May 1 under Trump or in 10 years.  

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, WhatTheBuck said:

Charlie Wilson disagrees. We washed our hands and walked away.

Interesting choice of words, though. Have you read the book by that title? That was my doorway into a whole lot of reading about the second Bush administration and the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.

3c56fa2b-bcf4-43fa-b476-0869ac65274d_1.c


Of course. It was fantastic. That's why I chose those words.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My understanding is that there never has and never will be a central ‘government’ in the traditional sense.  There are so many tribes, allegiances, families, foreigners and other loose organizations there…many of which have gone on for centuries…that whoever is present and has the most cohesive ability to enforce rules is who maintains the power.  
 

How can you expect to successfully manage that position?  A country that has never known (or appeared to want) a ‘modern’ lifestyle and centralized identity/system of governance, will not fight to (re)gain one.  Germany, and to a lesser extent Japan, had the recent memories of a peaceful and organized system to revert back to…they just needed a model change away from authoritarian, war-driven cult of personalities.  


ISIS cannot recognize a state, as to do so goes against their requirement of a worldwide caliphate.  The Taliban at least appear to do so, and even if their own is a brutally fundamentalist horror show, at least it can be a somewhat cohesive unit.  I’d love to see them turned against China in some proxy fashion, as a way to divert resources away from their growing dominance in the region…maybe that’s the next empire to lay waste there (though I’m not sure how that’d happen except via some regional conflict that they feel inclined to engage in). 
 

Shoulda been a special forces / air power playground of hunting down extremist leadership to keep their influence local and in check…seems once a commitment of large amounts of regular forces got involved, the end was written (as believe been stated here before).   I have nothing but appreciation for those who served, and gave so much to fight over there on endless tours.  
 

Then again I’m not a vet and not qualified to do anything but sit here in the safety of my shitter posting opinions with you assholes.  

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On March 5, 1975 the CIA and US Army Intelligence predicted South Vietnam could hold out until mid 1976.  On March 10th, the North Vietnamese army started marching towards Saigon.  By April 27, they has surrounded Saigon with the South Vietnamese army essentially melting away.  On April 30, the North Vietnamese Army began their attack.  At 10:24 am, the South Vietnamese surrendered.  The Vietnam War was over.  Twenty years of American blood and treasure went poof.

Sound familiar?

  • Hook 'Em 1
  • Rage+1 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, Hornius Emeritus said:

Of course. It was fantastic. That's why I chose those words.

I think you either have to believe that we shirked our responsibilities to the Afghans after the Russians left or that it was wrong to arm and support the mujahideen in the first place. You can’t have it both ways. I think history proves that.

And yeah, that’s a great book. Currently I’m taking this little trip down memory lane:

419hRwGEioL._SL500_.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Aqua Buddha said:

On March 5, 1975 the CIA and US Army Intelligence predicted South Vietnam could hold out until mid 1976.  On March 10th, the North Vietnamese army started marching towards Saigon.  By April 27, they has surrounded Saigon with the South Vietnamese army essentially melting away.  On April 30, the North Vietnamese Army began their attack.  At 10:24 am, the South Vietnamese surrendered.  The Vietnam War was over.  Twenty years of American blood and treasure went poof.

Sound familiar?

I posted something about this on the Biden thread.  We should blame Gerald Ford for the Vietnam War based on many peoples reactions today towards Biden.

  • Hook 'Em 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, DDD Dad said:


And the finger pointing commences.

Your creative editing of my post is ridiculous. He is not doing a good job with the pull out, meaning it's looking like he took the wrong advice, and assessment of his military, and political advisors, but the situation in, and of itself isn't his fault.

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Your creative editing of my post is ridiculous. He is not doing a good job with the pull out, meaning it's looking like he took the wrong advice, and assessment of his military, and political advisors, but the situation in, and of itself isn't his fault.

My point is that you are criticizing him.

Stop fucking finger pointing.

This is a tragedy for the Afghan people on a huge scale.

We as the western world have utterly failed them.

Period.
  • Hook 'Em 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, DDD Dad said:


My point is that you are criticizing him.

Stop fucking finger pointing.

This is a tragedy for the Afghan people on a huge scale.

We as the western world have utterly failed them.

Period.

No I won't that's my prerogative as a citizen, and I don't think it's really gonna affect the situation one way or another.  So... on your way brah...

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Brisketexan said:


Quite probably. But there’s not much we can do….

Theres tons of things we can do. We can recognize that their voices are important and respect their culture. We can commend the POTUS for the clarity of purpose of his statement and his action. We can make the Taliban know that the world is watching its actions. 

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

No I won't that's my prerogative as a citizen, and I don't think it's really gonna affect the situation one way or another.  So... on your way brah...
 

Ok cool. Hook em.

Note that I’ve not tried to deflect the current administration’s handling of this by referring to any other administration but you do you.

Keep it up. Your approach is only adding to the problem.

Also, I try to avoid neg repping but you’re asking for it.
  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, DDD Dad said:


Ok cool. Hook em.

Note that I’ve not tried to deflect the current administration’s handling of this by referring to any other administration but you do you.

Keep it up. Your approach is only adding to the problem.

Whatever man, go away.  

 

EDIT:  Jesus dude fuck you to. This is the CR and people talk politics, and complain about, and politicians.

Edited by Onboard 2.0
  • Fuck You 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Shrub got us in this mess. Obama killed Bin Ladin. Trump promised to end the endless wars, didn’t, and wanted to invite the taliban to camp David on 9-11. Signs a ridiculous deal. Biden then nuts up and finally gets us out.

See a pattern here?

Edited by JimmyJames
  • Hook 'Em 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Theres tons of things we can do. We can recognize that their voices are important and respect their culture. We can commend the POTUS for the clarity of purpose of his statement and his action. We can make the Taliban know that the world is watching its actions. 

So….like I said….not much.

Maybe we can replace the Space Force with a “Write a strongly worded letter” force.” That should do it.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, Onboard 2.0 said:

Whatever man, go away.  

 

EDIT:  Jesus dude fuck you to. This is the CR and people talk politics, and complain about, and politicians.

I mean, you asked me to neg  you. What did you expect. I just complied. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 minutes ago, 52-80 said:

Theres tons of things we can do. We can recognize that their voices are important and respect their culture. We can commend the POTUS for the clarity of purpose of his statement and his action. We can make the Taliban know that the world is watching its actions. 

Platitudes don’t accomplish jack shit. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Republicans, Democrats, UN, Whitehall. 
 

there’s plenty of blame to throw at everyone. 
 

there's a human crisis unfolding in front of us and everyone is sitting on their hands. 
 

FUCK!

 

let’s point fingers at each other; that seems to be productive. 

Edited by DDD Dad
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Fuck y’all trying to make this political. The war should have ended a decade ago. Hell, we can pretty much all agree we should have left the moment OBL was killed. Some can a even argue we never should have invaded in the first place (though this is less clear cut than the disaster that is Iraqi invasion). 
 

that said, our pullout is an absolute shit show.  Everyone has known for months we were leaving by September at the latest, why was getting our allies out not expedited?    Biden’s decision to leave was great. The actual process is a disaster that will cost countless live and is just one black eye in an absolute disaster of a “war”. 

Edited by Xian
  • Hook 'Em 2
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The history of this region going back for Millennia is wars are fought from March to October. 
 

Anyone want to explain to me why we decided to do a troop draw down and final pull out (when we would be at our most vulnerable from a political and visual aspect ) while we are still in this window?

 

Trump wanted to get it done in before the spring. He lost and it didn’t happen.  Why did we still move forward on this insane timeline instead of waiting?

This failure falls completely on the current administration for not having a plan.  The lack of understanding of the culture and political climate of this region is the reason this failure is happening now. There is no other explanation for how poorly this is playing out.

Edited by Laxtonto
  • Hook 'Em 3
  • Fuck You 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Laxtonto said:

The history of this region going back for Millennia is wars are fought from March to October. 
 

Anyone want to explain to me why we decided to do a troop draw down and final pull out (when we would be at our most vulnerable from a political and visual aspect ) while we are still in this window?

 

Trump wanted to get it done in before the spring. He lost and it didn’t happen.  Why did we still move forward on this insane timeline instead of waiting?

This failure falls completely on the current administration for not having a plan.  The lack of understanding of the culture and political climate of this region is the reason this failure is happening now. There is no other explanation for how handle this playing out.

If he really wanted it to happen then maybe trump should have withdrawn last December while he was still president.

I guess he was too busy planning his coup though.

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Laxtonto said:

The history of this region going back for Millennia is wars are fought from March to October. 
 

Anyone want to explain to me why we decided to do a troop draw down and final pull out (when we would be at our most vulnerable from a political and visual aspect ) while we are still in this window?

 

Trump wanted to get it done in before the spring. He lost and it didn’t happen.  Why did we still move forward on this insane timeline instead of waiting?

This failure falls completely on the current administration for not having a plan.  The lack of understanding of the culture and political climate of this region is the reason this failure is happening now. There is no other explanation for how handle this playing out.

The administration wanted to be out by the 20th anniversary of 9/11. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Lobwedgephil said:

We are now sending 7,000 troops to evacuate our people, not sure they will get there in time. This is up from 4,000 a few days ago. 

Maybe a stupid question, but now that the Taliban has taken over the capital, do we even have the ability to put 7000 troops on the ground to evac all our people without it being a full combat operation?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

38 minutes ago, Hookah Horns said:

It's pretty amazing that just 4 days ago "US intelligence" said Kabul could be isolated in 30 days and potentially taken over in as little as 90 days. Solid analysis. 

Does the timeline really matter though?   I mean whether it took 30-90 days or 30-90 minutes for Kabul to fall it was going to happen either way and people would bitch about it no matter how quickly it happened. We may have messed up the pullout at this point but it was bound to be a shit show no matter what we did and the Taliban were going to regain control.  I feel bad for the people of Afghanistan but let’s remember that there are countries where people are treated like crap by brutal regimes all over Asia, Africa, South America, etc… and we unfortunately can’t invade all of these countries and get rid of the bad guys either.  The world has some evil people that gain power and do evil things and you can’t just blame the United States.  Not that we don’t do bad stuff also and screw things up diplomatically sometimes but Afghanistan falling to the Taliban is not the United States fault.  If we never went in 20 years ago I am guessing the Taliban would have been in power for the past 20 years and still going strong.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • immamac changed the title to Afghan War ending, foretold by The Onion 10 years Ago [DT thread ruined by politics]


×
×
  • Create New...