Jump to content

so bank failures are back


Gil Bang

Recommended Posts

2 hours ago, Gil Bang said:

well, one anyway. 

The Enloe State Bank of Cooper, TX just got padlocked. 

There was a time that 3 or 4 of these happened every Friday.  Let's hope we don't get back there. 

anything you want to tell us GB?

https://myparistexas.com/update-state-fire-marshal-atf-investigating-fire-at-enloe-state-bank-in-cooper/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Lobo

So banks are becoming more mobile/digitization friendly which increases efficiencies and reduces wasteful branch G&A?  Which should reduce costs to consumers and/or raise interest payments, yes?

But last year, banks spent (wasted) more money on branch real estate costs than any other year in history?  

So they're investing R&D in fintech/mobility ease of use for the customers while doubling down on their dumbest fucking assets---real estate and personnel?  And they wonder why consumers aren't applauding?  They know that spending more on both real estate and tech R&D is going to screw them in the end, you fucking child.  I can't believe bank real estate spaces are being vacated faster than Sears.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, Lobo said:

So banks are becoming more mobile/digitization friendly which increases efficiencies and reduces wasteful branch G&A?  Which should reduce costs to consumers and/or raise interest payments, yes?

But last year, banks spent (wasted) more money on branch real estate costs than any other year in history?  

So they're investing R&D in fintech/mobility ease of use for the customers while doubling down on their dumbest fucking assets---real estate and personnel?  And they wonder why consumers aren't applauding?  They know that spending more on both real estate and tech R&D is going to screw them in the end, you fucking child.  I can't believe bank real estate spaces are being vacated faster than Sears.  

Capital One is building coffee shops.  I facepalm every time I see that commercial.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Found out today that my old man, who has been running running his own business for the last 40 years, has already been doing direct deposit on paychecks for quite a while.  So a bunch of redneck, oil field hands don't even get a check on payday anymore.  Just a statement.  So why do banks need physical locations again?  Seems like a spot for an ATM is all you need.  And I don't know how much longer you'll need even that. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They should combine with Walgreens or whoever. They are on every corner. I've never understood why banks started making so many branches after the atm was invented. Let alone our options now. I just assume small business customer traffic keeps them going

Link to comment
Share on other sites

51 minutes ago, SpiralOut said:

Found out today that my old man, who has been running running his own business for the last 40 years, has already been doing direct deposit on paychecks for quite a while.  So a bunch of redneck, oil field hands don't even get a check on payday anymore.  Just a statement.  So why do banks need physical locations again?  Seems like a spot for an ATM is all you need.  And I don't know how much longer you'll need even that. 

I don't think you know how banks work

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, mycox said:

I don't think you know how banks work

My bank account agrees with you.

It's all numbers on a computer, right?  Doesn't seem like you need expensive buildings/real estate to handle numbers.  I haven't been inside a bank in years.  App on the phone.  E-statements.  Customer assistance through their website.    

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Updawg said:

They should combine with Walgreens or whoever. They are on every corner. I've never understood why banks started making so many branches after the atm was invented. Let alone our options now. I just assume small business customer traffic keeps them going

You ever walked into an empty bank though?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You guys bitching about branches probably don't realize how much shit banks, especially the larger ones get when they close branches....particularly if it is a branch located in or near a minority/majority area.  Closings get politicized real quick.  

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I’d think most banks get foot traffic as a result of brick and mortar w/ high cash flow, small business loans, mortgages/car notes, and old people investing in basic financial instruments. Don’t think that’s going anywhere and I’d probably argue that additional bank front real estate is needed and the market is acting accordingly.

 

Taking it a step further, I’d also argue that if all those things I mentioned are increasing proportionally to the overall population, which results in more bank fronts opening, probably an overall indicator of a healthy and growing economy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 hours ago, DaysOff said:

Haven't walked in a physical bank in almost 3 years.

9 years.  And I've bought 2 cars and a house since then.  And the last time I did go to get a car loan, they tried to talk me out of actually going to branch.  My dad went to a usaa branch that wouldnt even take his cash.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've been with USAA for over 20 years.   Until recently, the only ATMs were in the San Antonio area and on military bases with almost no branches.   About 2-3 years ago, I noticed one in Porter about 6 miles from me.   A quick Google check tells me there are 3 in the greater Houston area.    Guess how many times I have used any of them?   ZERO.  

My paycheck is direct deposit.  I can deposit the few checks I get with my phone.   So tell me again why we need bank branches everywhere?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I still bank with the little hometown bank I've used since 1974, but that's about to change. The bank president was my loan officer, but he retired. Now it's some kid I never heard of, nobody knows me by name and their app is a piece of shit. Really trying to find a reason to stay other than being too lazy to swap.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 6/1/2019 at 2:00 AM, SpiralOut said:

 So why do banks need physical locations again?  Seems like a spot for an ATM is all you need.  And I don't know how much longer you'll need even that. 

A lot of people in this country aren't living in 2019 like the rest of us. Friday was one of the busiest days in our history as far as in person transactions and walk in loans. I personally was slammed all day. I mean you have olds that get cash for the weekends. You have illegals cashing their pay checks. You have the retirees with nothing to do but we still make a profit off of them. Branches will die out and some are consolidating, but we aren't there yet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I joined USAA in 2008, so I haven't walked into a bank since.  However, the only time I miss having a physical location is when I have a large amount of cash to deposit.  USAA has had the mobile deposit for a decade or so, but I can't take pics of cash.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Lobo said:

So was my Sears store.  

Sears wasn't making $35 a pop off each poor  6 times a month for nothing in overdraft fees and then following that up with loans at 18% to clear it up until they inevitably fall back into overdraft land. The local bank model is outdated but they should stay in business long enough to get bought out by a midsize then they'll get rebranded and eventually closed.

Edited by SimonBolivar
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 6/1/2019 at 9:09 AM, Surly Bevo said:

You guys bitching about branches probably don't realize how much shit banks, especially the larger ones get when they close branches....particularly if it is a branch located in or near a minority/majority area.  Closings get politicized real quick.  

Those branch banks should be combined with a 7/11.

Two for one deal for the robbers. (/racist)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, RPM said:

I still bank with the little hometown bank I've used since 1974, but that's about to change. The bank president was my loan officer, but he retired. Now it's some kid I never heard of, nobody knows me by name and their app is a piece of shit. Really trying to find a reason to stay other than being too lazy to swap.

Your hometown bank has an app? That's big time!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, Jersey Man10 said:

Yeah my local bank will NEVER close. It's full of olds, business owners, and illegals lol.

Business owners (small and medium) still kind of do things the old fashioned way as far a mailing off payments and taking cash payments.   And the mailing off payments thing probably will not go away because some business owners have others do that for them in the way of a bookkeeper or another key employee.  My business is still small enough where I do most of my payments myself and on line, but once I can hand it off to another person as a I grow,  I would be hesitant to give him/her the keys to access my bank account on line.  Just a simple safe guard and nothing else.  

I was at a large national bank  helping my recent high school grad open his first account.   I remarked to him how quiet this place was compared to five years ago when I did the same for his brother.  But you are right most of the people coming in and out were of age and not us Gen X age or younger.   Also I noted the lines at the drive thru banking were way down.   One of the other big national banks down the street has added drive up ATMs to replace the traditional  teller.    

I  also have a Charles Schwab account which I use for travel purposes and before we go vacation or out of town for an extended period of time, I transfer money in to it.   They refund you all the ATM fees at the end of the month.   

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, SimonBolivar said:

You see a lot of people depositing money at Oxxo stores in Mexico.

Mexico is weird because many of their workers get paid via direct deposit.   But when  many get paid, they go to an ATM and withdraw all their cash.    Friday's at an ATM in Mexico can be headache, so it's a good idea if you fly in on a Friday , get Pesos at the Airport ATM's.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Lobo
2 hours ago, Dr. Beeper said:

For the industry or a particular bank?  Either way, I’m calling bullshit. 

40% (it may be 30-35% most other years, you get the idea) of the revenue from depository accounts for banks comes from overdraft fees.  Maintenance fees and ATM fees make up the rest.  Overdraft fees totaled $35 billion last year and it's going up.  Keep in mind that's on checking/savings accounts and some treasury management, not the bank's total revenue which is obviously driven mostly on the lending side.  That's industry-wide, not just my bank.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Lobo
Just now, Dr. Beeper said:

You just changed what you said. There’s a big big difference between depository revenue and revenue. 

Jesus Barbara, I wrote that at midnight.  Between 40% and revenue, I should have typed checking/savings or depository account or somesuch.  My bad.  I know a lot about banks but not much about raising a 2-month old and getting sleep.  I apologize, I'll delete the post if possible.  The statistic is the right.  The notion and critique of my industry still holds.  The general sense of where that side of the bank's money is coming from (it's 3x as much as they make on ATM fees which are all consumers complain about) is valid.  So yes, 40% on the checking/savings side comes from that, much more than maintenance or ATM fees.  Anything else I can address about an innocent detail left out of a one-handed, late-night post?  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Lobo

Yes, absolutely true.  I mentioned almost the very same sentiment as yours in post 42.  We were talking about the depository side yesterday and so that 40% thing was on my mind, again I did not qualify it properly when discussing revenue.  Still it makes up a large portion of that side of the ledger.  

Now the really fun thing is when they game the lag time and hold periods on that side of a bank to "encourage" overdrafts.  Because it's not just the overdraft fee anymore, it's how it can help drive revenue on the lending side.  Anybody with any kind of home loan, HELOC, auto loan, etc. through their bank.  First thing they offer you is a little 15bps savings here, 10bps there, 50bps there.  All for stuff like keeping a Gold level checking account active there, agreeing to have auto-withdrawal to repay the loan on xx date of the month, maintaining a balance in savings of 3mos of the debt, whatever.  All those little digital-age perks they "throw in" to shave a little off your loan payment here and there.  Well, most of those little perks have a 1 or 2 strike and you're out penalty on them.  You overdraft and don't have the full amount to make that payment, and your rate skyrockets, you may get charged points, and all the little rate shavings go back up to full freight.  And what happens more than that is you have one lag on a deposit and you're still fine making your payments, but you fall below that agreed-upon benchmark like keeping $10k in checking/savings at all times or whatever to stay eligible for some lower rate on your auto loan (a crude example), and so again ---the customer loses all those rate savings tools they were first eligible for. /rant

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So back to branches  and their usefulness. I run a small branch in a fairly impoverished area and so far this morning (3rd of the month so Social Security day for a lot of the olds) our drive thru ATM has had 10 transactions and my tellers have had 42, 38, and 42 transactions and we've only been open for an hour and a half. I've also done two walk in auto loans with 0 online or phone apps so far today. A lot of Americans are incredibly slow to adapt to change.

Edited by SimonBolivar
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...