Jump to content

Health Insurance fuckery


Fastbreak

Recommended Posts

Quote

Olympic gymnastics champion Mary Lou Retton is “fighting for her life” in an intensive care unit, according to her daughter.

Retton has been diagnosed with “a very rare form of pneumonia” and has been in the ICU at an undisclosed hospital for more than a week “not able to breathe on her own”, McKenna Kelley said in an Instagram story posted on Tuesday afternoon.

“Out of respect for her and her privacy, I will not disclose all details,” wrote Kelley, a former gymnast at Louisiana State University. “However, I will disclose that she is not insured.”

She added: “We ask that if you could help in any way, that 1) you PRAY! and 2) if you could help us with finances for the hospital bill.”

She should have won more gold medals - am i right?
---

What the fuck is wrong with us that we have these kinds of stories every day?  It's disgusting that health care is some kind of special benefit that now only the ultra rich can really afford.  The health of the nation is basically controlled by few insurance companies and lobbyist.  The system only benefits them AND the fucking rubes go along with it.  Why does everything have to be fucked up when it is so simple to fix?

  • Hook 'Em 2
  • Like 1
  • Rage+1 6
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So the best insurance plan is:

1. Be famous
(Get sick)
2. Start a go fund me

A big problem is everyone thinks they are going to be famous or rich. Almost all of my redneck relatives think they are days away from being a millionaire or a tik-tok sensation.

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This sucks. My wife tells stories about her from their college days. Get well, MLR.

Not having insurance, and insurance not covering her illness, are not the same thing. I wouldn’t put it past bean counter types to decide that breathing on her own, without the help of a machine, is “not medically necessary.” At least, that’s what Blue Cross and Blue Shield wanted to say about paying for cataract surgery: not medically necessary. I had one good eye. How many does it take to see? 
 

Single payer. 

  • Hook 'Em 8
  • Rage+1 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Health insurance system sucks horribly, but there's little reason not to have it with Obamacare.

If you have a low income, the plans are cheap. You get dinged when you make a little bit of money to where you don't get subsidies but not enough to where the cost is easy to stomach. Our family of three is paying about $850 a month.

The insurance is shit (high deductibles/out of pocket maximums), but it is coverage.

But yes, the entire system is just atrocious.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Obamacare system has been very frustrating for me personally. I can't use it, because the doctor networks offered are so poor, I can't count on it to cover critical doctors my wife and I need for some unusual health issues. But, since we both didn't work, we couldn't get any other insurance due to health issues.

So the only alternative was to have one of us go back to work solely for health insurance. It's ridiculous. Twelve years ago, before Obamacare, we could get on a Texas health exchange that was relatively affordable as compared to corporate health plan premiums, covered a wide range of doctors, and required no medical questionnaires. 

Obamacare has been good for a sliver of the population that don't need good care, and don't have to go to the doctor. It's almost worthless for low income people because of the sky high deductibles. My friend offered partial Obamacare coverage to all of his employees and none of them took it, because the deductibles made it not make sense. In their minds, they were better off just rolling the dice and using the money saved from not paying premiums to use towards any costs. And if they had a major expense, just don't pay it.  The whole system is so screwed up.

  • Rage+1 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I also love the "my employer pays my insurance" angle.  When i had my own company we were paying on average $900 a month per employee and then they would pay around $450 or so (this is 10 years ago, video games with average employee age <30).  So that is $1350 a month that somehow is a "benefit" without anyone thinking that it would be much nicer to have the cash in pocket each month and not have to worry about paying off some corporation whose sole goal is to make money on your health and to fuck you without lube whenever possible.

  • Hook 'Em 5
  • Rage+1 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, MrBig said:

I’m sure her bill is going to skyrocket from the “self-pay” prices to the “go fund me” prices.

It won't cover it.  When I got stents in 2014, I was in the hospital for 5 days. The bill was $210,000.  That'd probably be $350,000+ in today's dollars and inflated costs.

  • Rage+1 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The whole industry makes no sense.

My wife has a prescription for migraines. It has always been free under our insurance.

One day she goes to get a refill and they say "that will be 400 dollars"

Long story short, they had tried to fill it for 20 pills when it had always been 19 pills. 19 pills is free, but 20 pills is 400 bucks.

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
  • Rage+1 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, CooterBrown said:

It won't cover it.  When I got stents in 2014, I was in the hospital for 5 days. The bill was $210,000.  That'd probably be $350,000+ in today's dollars and inflated costs.

 

My 2 hour outpatient right shoulder surgery (torn labrum, rotator cuff, etc) was $55,000 in early 2020.  And I didn't even get a fucking meal out of the hospital.

 

 

  • Rage+1 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Retton’s story is a prime example of why you have to have some health insurance even with ridiculous deductibles and limited benefits. If you don’t have insurance, you’re rolling the dice that you won’t be hospitalized. If you lose, it can wreck the finances of you and others.

our system has many flaws but that doesnt absolve someone from being responsible based on the current rules. 

  • Hook 'Em 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My health industry sucks story was from 20+ years ago when one of my kids was born and hospital bill had an item on it for $1,000 or such for extra night in hospital. I questioned them and they said insurance wouldn't cover it to which I explained I was told they might not, but was also told it would be $300 if they didn't. They straight faced said - that's the cash pay rate, because you have insurance it's $1000 and since they won't pay you owe $1000 because you are on the "insured" rate plan.

  • Rage+1 4
  • Drool 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My wife was on bedrest for a month and my son was in the NICU for 2 months. They processed my insurance wrong and I got a bill for $1.1 million. I'll never for the life of me understand how a bunch of poor bastards are okay with this because the same party is suppressing made up trans threats or whatever. 

  • Hook 'Em 4
  • Rage+1 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, MonkeyDoughnut said:

My health industry sucks story was from 20+ years ago when one of my kids was born and hospital bill had an item on it for $1,000 or such for extra night in hospital. I questioned them and they said insurance wouldn't cover it to which I explained I was told they might not, but was also told it would be $300 if they didn't. They straight faced said - that's the cash pay rate, because you have insurance it's $1000 and since they won't pay you owe $1000 because you are on the "insured" rate plan.

I know you can’t easily shop hospitals like other products in the world, but you sometimes have to research, push back, and ask for alternatives. Especially with medication. My mom had some new medicine that would cost between 50-75 per month with using her insured rate. Not back breaking but more than she used to pay. I found that HEB would charge $6 per month cash price. Sold. See ya CVS.

I even find that pharmacists will help you identify alternatives or different dosages that significantly lower costs. Take that info to the doc to get their thoughts.

Ive been in line behind people that chew out the pharmacy tech who has no control over the costs. Treat them with respect and you might find they can help you. Work with the system not against it.

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, Nice Guy Eddie said:

Retton’s story is a prime example of why you have to have some health insurance even with ridiculous deductibles and limited benefits. If you don’t have insurance, you’re rolling the dice that you won’t be hospitalized. If you lose, it can wreck the finances of you and others.

our system has many flaws but that doesnt absolve someone from being responsible based on the current rules. 

Yep.  And ZERO defense of the current approach, by the way.  But when I turned 25, I went off my parents' insurance.  Wasn't going to start a job that offered insurance for like 5 more months.  Texas Exes offered a bare-bones health insurance plan that I just called my "if I get hit by a bus" insurance.

Didn't pay for shit in terms of basic Dr. visits.  High deductible.  BUT, if I got hit by a bus, or diagnosed with a serious illness, etc., I wouldn't get stuck with a $1 million bill.  It was cheap, but that was also over 25 years ago.  Maybe $100 a month?  Also, I was 25, so pretty low risk of getting seriously ill.

Having "hit by a bus" basic insurance really is important to do if you can pull it off at all.  Looks like Texas Exes still offers a similar plan, but it's just a short-term thing: https://www.texasexes.org/membership/member-benefits/short-term-medical-insurance

 

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Captainant said:

Your mentioning eyes is it's own frustration - eye and dental care isn't covered in a normal healthcare plan. Because you don't need good vision or teeth right?

When my dad was still alive it was like going to fucking war to get any sort of PT for his Parkinson's. They'd just send us some resistance bands and say "thoughts and prayers!" and do jack shit.

"""Health""" insurance companies exist solely to leech off of medical transactions and skim profits off for their shareholders. They have pushed costs up, given us months long wait times to get medical care, and worst of all, given us anastasis. It's an industry that should not exist and has a fundamentally flawed business model. 

Everyone is gonna get sick and need care. We should not allow profit driven and GREEDY hangers-on to interject themselves into our medical decisions. It's not for our benefit. It's for the benefit of their shareholders. 

Actually, things having to do with your eyes can -- and does -- fall under your normal health care plan. Routine eye exams, contacts and eyeglass prescriptions is "Vision" but most anything beyond that falls under medical plan.

The medical insurance program in this country is bat shit insane. Carriers slow-pay or simply don't pay doctors so the doctors have increased their costs to make up the difference. It's grift from all sides unfortunately and we carry the burden as a populace. The rest of the world has this so much better figured out than us. I know this won't be fixed in my lifetime.

 

22 minutes ago, Nice Guy Eddie said:

Retton’s story is a prime example of why you have to have some health insurance even with ridiculous deductibles and limited benefits. If you don’t have insurance, you’re rolling the dice that you won’t be hospitalized. If you lose, it can wreck the finances of you and others.

our system has many flaws but that doesnt absolve someone from being responsible based on the current rules. 

As many of you know, I'm in the insurance world (property and casualty) but have my life/health license. Unfortunately, we're getting to a state where insurance is only going to be good for catastrophic type situations (house burns down, gets washed away by a flood/hurricane, etc) in my world. Same in the health world. Yeah, it's frustrating that my PCP decides to double-code my annual physical so he can "earn" a well visit in addition to billing insurance for my "free" physical (I'm shopping PCP's, BTW) but that's a pittance in the grand scheme of things if I get diagnosed with cancer or am injured in a major auto accident and my care is in the millions. It's inconceivable that Retton doesn't have some form of catastrophic, high deductible health insurance at an absolute minimum.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Brisketexan said:

Yep.  And ZERO defense of the current approach, by the way.  But when I turned 25, I went off my parents' insurance.  Wasn't going to start a job that offered insurance for like 5 more months.  Texas Exes offered a bare-bones health insurance plan that I just called my "if I get hit by a bus" insurance.

Didn't pay for shit in terms of basic Dr. visits.  High deductible.  BUT, if I got hit by a bus, or diagnosed with a serious illness, etc., I wouldn't get stuck with a $1 million bill.  It was cheap, but that was also over 25 years ago.  Maybe $100 a month?  Also, I was 25, so pretty low risk of getting seriously ill.

Having "hit by a bus" basic insurance really is important to do if you can pull it off at all.  Looks like Texas Exes still offers a similar plan, but it's just a short-term thing: https://www.texasexes.org/membership/member-benefits/short-term-medical-insurance

 

Well said.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, Nice Guy Eddie said:

I know you can’t easily shop hospitals like other products in the world, but you sometimes have to research, push back, and ask for alternatives. Especially with medication. My mom had some new medicine that would cost between 50-75 per month with using her insured rate. Not back breaking but more than she used to pay. I found that HEB would charge $6 per month cash price. Sold. See ya CVS.

I even find that pharmacists will help you identify alternatives or different dosages that significantly lower costs. Take that info to the doc to get their thoughts.

Ive been in line behind people that chew out the pharmacy tech who has no control over the costs. Treat them with respect and you might find they can help you. Work with the system not against it.

Agreed, next time anyone goes to pick up prescription, ask what the cash price would have been. On many prescriptions my copay is above the cash price.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

During my 2 year sabbatical I had the bottom tier Obamacare plan but only considered it catastrophic insurance. Useless for anything under 15k (or whatever the deductible was).

The subsidy was another FU to poor people. No subsidy if you made less than ~40k.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's tragic, from an economic efficiency POV, when someone opts out of insurance or even a visit to the doctor to save <$500. Then they end up in the ICU for $10,000+ per day. Then we get the Go Fund Me asking others to help out with that 5 or 6 figure bill.

Some people can avoid hospital visits by taking care of the initial illness for less than $50. For an upper respiratory ailment, you can see a nurse practitioner via a smart phone for $25 and the prescription could be as low as $5. Now Retton has something her daughter described as a rare pneumonia, so maybe it does require a lengthy hospital stay and can't be avoided. I don't know.

Disclaimer: I'm not blaming sick people. I'm blaming that we have a bad system and we don't educate people how best to navigate it.

  • Hook 'Em 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, MonkeyDoughnut said:

Agreed, next time anyone goes to pick up prescription, ask what the cash price would have been. On many prescriptions my copay is above the cash price.

GoodRx should be everyone's friend if they have frequent prescriptions. The app tells you the non-insurance rate at nearby pharmacies. Now it doesn't count against any insurance deductible but that may not matter.

Also push back on doctors is they prescribe an expensive option. Do you need a Ferrari medication if a Yugo will do.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

58 minutes ago, Nice Guy Eddie said:

Retton’s story is a prime example of why you have to have some health insurance even with ridiculous deductibles and limited benefits. If you don’t have insurance, you’re rolling the dice that you won’t be hospitalized. If you lose, it can wreck the finances of you and others.

our system has many flaws but that doesnt absolve someone from being responsible based on the current rules. 

It doesn't matter if you have insurance.  When I got stents and the $210,000 bill, UnitedHealthCare denied the claim based on the idea that I should've never been admitted to the hospital for undetermined chest pain, so the blockage should've never been discovered.  It didn't matter that my PCP sent me over to see a cardiologist immediately and he told me to go get admitted ASAP.  

The only luck in the whole situation was that I went to Seton and UHC's contract with Seton stated that the hospital had to eat the cost of denied claims beyond my copays.

One night in the hospital, the overnight doctor that came in to look at my chart and was there for 1 minute charged me $1,700. He was out of network so I had to pay that out of pocket as if I had a choice to see him.

 

 

 

  • Rage+1 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, CooterBrown said:

It doesn't matter if you have insurance.  When I got stents and the $210,000 bill, UnitedHealthCare denied the claim based on the idea that I should've never been admitted to the hospital for undetermined chest pain, so the blockage should've never been discovered.  It didn't matter that my PCP sent me over to see a cardiologist immediately and he told me to go get admitted ASAP.  

The only luck in the whole situation was that I went to Seton and UHC's contract with Seton stated that the hospital had to eat the cost of denied claims beyond my copays.

One night in the hospital, the overnight doctor that came in to look at my chart and was there for 1 minute charged me $1,700. He was out of network so I had to pay that out of pocket as if I had a choice to see him.

 

 

 

The whole in-network / out of network is bullshit. Why is that responsibility on the patient when most times they did everything they could to stay in network.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

26 minutes ago, CooterBrown said:

It doesn't matter if you have insurance.  When I got stents and the $210,000 bill, UnitedHealthCare denied the claim based on the idea that I should've never been admitted to the hospital for undetermined chest pain, so the blockage should've never been discovered.  It didn't matter that my PCP sent me over to see a cardiologist immediately and he told me to go get admitted ASAP.  

The only luck in the whole situation was that I went to Seton and UHC's contract with Seton stated that the hospital had to eat the cost of denied claims beyond my copays.

One night in the hospital, the overnight doctor that came in to look at my chart and was there for 1 minute charged me $1,700. He was out of network so I had to pay that out of pocket as if I had a choice to see him.

It did matter for you that you had insurance. You wrote that UHC kept you from paying $210K because of UHC's contract with Seton. That's was a worthwhile benefit for you.

And the stories of people receiving $200K or $1M dollar bills are crazy to see, but it's common to see that much of the bill is commonly eliminated later on. It's why I'm also skeptical when someone is asking for funds in a Go Fund Me while they're still in the hospital. There is time to see what the bill will ultimately be resolved to.

Edited by Nice Guy Eddie
  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, MonkeyDoughnut said:

The whole in-network / out of network is bullshit. Why is that responsibility on the patient when most times they did everything they could to stay in network.

While this situation could occur, there are new controls to prevent surprise billing to the patient who did everything they could.

It doesn't mean that you won't receive a large bill but a bill does not equate to the money leaving your bank account. Call and ask questions. Worse case, you can appeal to a state board about it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Our healthcare system sucks, but if you have a disease or chronic issues and you get good coverage at a good price, it's a blessing but your job becomes a shackle. If you don't have rare or extreme diseases and illnesses, a basic, socialized healthcare like what the UK has in NHS would be awesome. If you do need more critical and specialized support, you will be left with a lot to be desired that will impact your speed (and efficacy) of treatment and quality of care.

Personally, I have a rare disease. My treatment and medical team of specialists would be prohibitively expensive out of pocket for one month, much less one year. 

Because of this, I will always have to work for an employer who offers great medical insurance and, thank God, up to this point I have had the luxury. That is somewhat limiting in that I can never start a business or work for retire early, but it's my lot in life. 

That said, because my disease is rare I'm in a small community of us going through it. A lot of them are in Europe. My best mate with this disease who I trade the most notes with is in the UK. The horror stories bout the NHS I hear from him on just simple approvals like necessary medicines and wait times is horrible and actually makes me grateful for the quality of care and insurance coverage I'm privileged to have.

His quality of care is really poor compared to what I can get using Aetna, BCBS or United Healthcare (ranked in that order of good to bad). One example, I require a $100k chemo-lite infusion, 3x a year, which is a crucial part of the treatment. I have specialists for every facet of my disease. It wasn't the easiest thing to get approved but with a little push from your medical team it gets done. He has one general doctor who isn't well-versed in the rare disease and he has been denied three times, while waiting TWO AND A HALF YEARS, and it's like the old Pawn Stars meme, "the best I can do is a generic basic pill rx that doesn't really work", because it's cheap.

 

Edited by BeardIP
  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, texasdago said:

Our system sucks so badly.  

All healthcare systems suck to some extent. There will always be limits in resources that either slow down care for some or all. It's prohibitively expensive to have services on demand for everyone.

Personally I think we should expand the ACA will full subsidies for more people. Keep the capitalistic system but let the govt pay for the poor(er) people.

  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Neonmoon said:

If only there was a system where everyone could get medical care...

Oh well, guess it's just one of those unsolvable mysteries like gun violence. 

 

image.png.5261cf0670d5fcd124d9f534e52c5ea4.png

I work for a Canadian company.  The U.S. employees have Aetna and the Canadians, obviously, have their single-payer HC.   

I have a colleague who has a kid with chronic HC issues and he HATES the Canadian system and envies the U.S. employees getting the ability to have private insurance.  Crazy shit. 

I've heard several nightmare scenarios from a handful of Canadian folks over the years.  No system is perfect. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, DigglerontheHoof said:

I work for a Canadian company.  The U.S. employees have Aetna and the Canadians, obviously, have their single-payer HC.   

I have a colleague who has a kid with chronic HC issues and he HATES the Canadian system and envies the U.S. employees getting the ability to have private insurance.  Crazy shit. 

I've heard several nightmare scenarios from a handful of Canadian folks over the years.  No system is perfect. 

No shit? Well I know these 3 million Americans and they owe over 10,000 in medical debt they can’t afford. I also heard that Humira was 427% more expensive in the US than the UK. 

It sucks about your colleagues kid, but they can buy private insurance if they are not satisfied with the single payer 

  • Hook 'Em 6
Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, Nice Guy Eddie said:

All healthcare systems suck to some extent. There will always be limits in resources that either slow down care for some or all. It's prohibitively expensive to have services on demand for everyone.

Personally I think we should expand the ACA will full subsidies for more people. Keep the capitalistic system but let the govt pay for the poor(er) people.

I think the answer has to be something like this. Cheap/Free healthcare for the easy peasy stuff, for the 80% of Americans who are only impacted by the common maladies and the common emergencies (from broken bones to heart attacks) and the private/employer premium care for the 20% of Americans who need the expensive, rare, and/or specialized care or who want the best doctors, the fastest care, their personal choice of facilities, etc.

The problem there is you will hear how unfair it is that the 80% of the healthcare has the least prestigious providers and abilities and longest wait times, etc., but the common American isn't aware of the deficiencies of things like NHS or the Canadian system as mentioned above, and thinks they will be getting premium for free and it just can't work that way financially.

Edited by BeardIP
  • Hook 'Em 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Nice Guy Eddie said:

It doesn't mean that you won't receive a large bill but a bill does not equate to the money leaving your bank account. Call and ask questions. Worse case, you can appeal to a state board about it.

The first sentence is key. And the last sentence is unfortunately the last resort for many people, but for me a few times I've simply never paid. I have always and always will pay debts that I agreed to. 

But if you think I'm paying you $1700 for one minute of attention without telling me how much it would be you can fuck right off. You will never see that money. Same with an ambulance bill once. The EMTs administered smelling salts and drove my daughter 4 miles. $2500. Haha fuck you. Nope. On that one I researched rates for the same service in the area and got two numbers at $1500 and $1600. Absurd in their own right but I called and said I'd pay $1600 to settle. They said they don't negotiate. I said cool, you'll get nothing. 

I realize there are reasons not everyone can do that. But a lot more people can than realize it. Too many people consider themselves prisoner to whatever number the provider pulls out of the air. 

  • Hook 'Em 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Huckleberry said:

The first sentence is key. And the last sentence is unfortunately the last resort for many people, but for me a few times I've simply never paid. I have always and always will pay debts that I agreed to. 

But if you think I'm paying you $1700 for one minute of attention without telling me how much it would be you can fuck right off. You will never see that money. Same with an ambulance bill once. The EMTs administered smelling salts and drove my daughter 4 miles. $2500. Haha fuck you. Nope. On that one I researched rates for the same service in the area and got two numbers at $1500 and $1600. Absurd in their own right but I called and said I'd pay $1600 to settle. They said they don't negotiate. I said cool, you'll get nothing. 

I realize there are reasons not everyone can do that. But a lot more people can than realize it. Too many people consider themselves prisoner to whatever number the provider pulls out of the air. 

Do you not have insurance? Hard to believe that you'd get a $2500 bill with insurance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have insurance and always have. There was some standard insurance fuckery, but in this case I actually understood BCBS's position that the rate was too far above reasonable market cost or whatever. So they went after me. They were just as successful as they were getting BCBS to pay any more than they did. 

Edited by Huckleberry
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



×
×
  • Create New...